www.geologicacarpathica.sk
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
, DECEMBER 2011, 62, 6, 501—517 doi: 10.2478/v10096-011-0036-5
Dasycladalean green algae and some problematic algae from
the Upper Triassic of the Nayband Formation (northeast Iran)
BABA SENOWBARI-DARYAN
1
, KOOROSH RASHIDI
2
and BEHNAM SABERZADEH
3
1
Geozentrum Nordbayern, University Erlangen-Nürnberg, Loewenichstrasse 28, 91054 Erlangen, Germany; basendar@pal.uni-erlangen.de
2
Payam-e Noor University (PNU), Ardakan/Yazd, Iran; Koo.rashidi@gmail.com
3
Islamic Azad University, Zarand Branch, Iran; Behnamsaber@yahoo.com
(Manuscript received January 17, 2011; accepted in revised form March 17, 2011)
Abstract: This paper describes the dasycladales green algae from two sections of the Rhaetian Howz-e Khan Member
of the Nayband Formation, northwest of the Dig-e Rostam motorway service area (south of the type locality of the
Formation near the town Naybandan). Both sections are composed of bedded fine-grained limestones containing partly
abundant dasycladales algae associated with foraminifers, which are mainly aulotortid types. Additionally scattered
samples were collected from several beds of the Howz-e Khan Member in this area. The following dasycladalean taxa
are described: Chinianella carpatica (Bystrický), Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel), Griphoporella lutensis nov. sp.,
some undetermined dasycladacean taxa, problematic algae like Lithocodium aggregatum Elliott, Bacinella irregularis
Radoicic, and Thaumatoporella parvovesiculifera (Raineri). While Chinianella carpatica is not numerous and the other
described algae are rare, Griphoporella curvata is extremely abundant in the investigated material. This paper describes
Ch. carpatica for the first time from the Triassic of Iran and also includes a discussion of the strong variability of
G. curvata. Additionally we include an informal description of a problematic fossil (animal: shell fragment?; plant: alga?).
Key words: Triassic, Iran, Nayband Formation, Green Algae, Dasycladales, Chinianella, Griphoporella, Gyroporella,
Lithocodium, Bacinella.
Introduction
Dasycladalean green algae are an abundant fossil group in
shallow-water carbonates, particularly in bedded limestones
of Upper Paleozoic and Lower Mesozoic deposits. They are
known from numerous localities around the world, especially
from the Tethyan Realm. General works about the environ-
mental distribution and diversity of Permian, Triassic, and
Jurassic dasycladales are given by Flügel (1975, 1979,
1985), and the stratigraphical range of Triassic dasycladales
were carried out by Ott (1972), Flügel (1991), and Bucur
(1999). A general work with synonymy-lists of all species of
Permian and Triassic dasycladaleans is published by Granier
& Grgasovic (2000).
Red algae (solenoporaceans) occur in the bio-construc-
tions of the Nayband Formation and are not described in this
paper. Triassic dasycladales are scarcely known from Iran,
but they are relatively abundant in the bedded limestones of
some Nayband Formation localities. Senowbari-Daryan &
Hamedani (2000) described the species of Diplopora, Gyro-
porella, and Acicullela from the Norian part of the Nayband
Formation (central Iran). The genus Acicullela is also report-
ed from the Triassic of the Zagros Mountains in southwest
Iran (Golestaneh 1979). Foraminifers, dasycladales, in-
cluding Poikiloporella duplicata, Clypeina besici, and
Teutloporella herculea and some problematic fossils were
described by Senowbari-Daryan (2003) from the Carnian of
the Nayband Mount, not far from the localities of dasyclad-
ales described in this paper. The problematic fossil Probolo-
cuspis espahkensis, described by Brönniman et al. (1974)
was identified in a section near the town of Espahk (south of
Tabas) and interpreted as dasycladales by Senowbari-Daryan
& Majidifard (2003). Furthermore, P. espahkensis and an-
other species of the genus – P. aculeate Nittel – are known
from the Wetterstein limestones (Ladinian—Carnian) of the
Northern Calcareous Alps, Austria (Nittel 2006).
Localities
The dasycladales, described in this paper are from two
bedded limestone sections of the Rhaetian Howz-e Khan
Member of the Nayband Formation. Both localities are situ-
ated in southwest area of the town of Naybandan, a small
town east of the type locality of the Nayband Formation
south of the Mount Nayband. Additionally scattered samples
were collected from locality 3 in Fig. 1. The field work was
done by the last two authors.
The first sampled section is located about 7 km southwest of
the town of Naybandan (Fig. 1). The locality can only be
reached on foot or by motorcycle. Approximately 160 rock-
pieces were sampled from the ~ 246 m thick section of grey,
bedded limestones. The lower part of the section, indicated as
locality 1 in Fig. 1 (N 32°18
’817”; E 57°27’213”) is com-
posed mainly of thick-bedded limestones without reef build-
ing organisms. In the upper part of the section some sponges
and corals occur. Thin sections, numbered “H” in plate expla-
nations are derived from this locality. The second section is
located about 15 km southwest of the town of Naybandan,
about 8 km southwest of the first section (Fig. 1)
(N 32°15
’917”; E 57°24’942”). The lowermost part of the
section is sandstone beds, continuing into carbonate beds of
502
SENOWBARI-DARYAN, RASHIDI and SABERZADEH
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, 2011, 62, 6, 501—517
the Rhaetian Howz-e Khan Member. 76 rock-pieces were col-
lected from this locality and are numbered “khk” in plate ex-
planations. All other thin sections are taken from the different
beds of the valley, lying north of the section 1 locality, indi-
cated with a thick line numbered “3” in Fig. 1. Thin sections,
marked “n” and “J” were collected from different area of the
Howz-e Khan Member in valley between the localities 2 and 3
in Fig. 1. The investigated thin sections are deposited in the
“Staatssammlung für Paläontologie und historische Geologie
in München, Inventar-Nr: BSPG 2010 XIII 1-48”.
Systematic paleontology
Family: Triploporellaceae Pia, 1920; emend. LoDuca, 1977
D e f i n i t i o n : “Thallus with euspondyle ramifications;
productive bodies endosporate or cladosporate” (LoDuca
1977: p. 943).
Tribe: Triploporelleae (Pia, 1920), Bassoullet et al., 1979
Genus: Chinianella Ott (not 1967), ex Granier & Deloffre,
1993: not 1994 as given in Granier & Grgasovic, 2000
R e m a r k s : There is some confusion about the name of the
genera Chinianella and Heteroporella Praturlon (1967). Ott
(1967: p. 215; date of the journal 15
th
December 1967) intro-
duced the genus name Chinianella with type species Cylin-
droporella ellenbergeri Lebouché & Lemoine (1963) and
added the two further species, Ch. crosi Ott and Ch. zankli Ott
to this genus. Ott (1968: date of the journal 15
th
December
1968) emended the genus Heteroporella Praturlon and attrib-
uted the species Ch. crosi and Ch. zankli to this genus. Granier
& Deloffre (1993: p. 26; see also Granier et al. 1994 and
Granier & Grgasocic 2000) re-introduced the genus name
Chinianella Ott with type species Ch. ellenbergeri and also in-
cluded the species Heteroporella carpatica Bystrický (date of
the publication and reprint is 1967, but erronneous reference
as cited by Granier & Deloffre 1993 is 1968; Granier et al.
1994; Granier & Grgasovic 2000) to this genus. Because
Chinianella zankli was attributed to a non valid genus at that
time by Ott (1967), therefore this species was also not valid.
Consequently Granier & Deloffre (1993), Granier et al.
(1994), and Granier & Grgasovic (2000) correctly synony-
mized Chinianella zankli Ott with Ch. carpatica (Bystrický).
The complete synonymy-list of Chinianella carpatica
(Bystrický) is given by Granier & Grgasovic (2000).
Chinianella carpatica (Bystrický), 1967
(date not given 1967 on reprint)
(Fig. 2A—I, Fig. 3)
*1967 Heteroporella carpatica sp. nov. – Bystrický, p. 302, pl. 15,
fig. 1—5, pl. 16, fig. 4
*1967 Chinianella zankli n. sp. – Ott, p. 219, pl. 13, Fig. 2—3, text
fig. 5/1—14
1968 Heteroporella zankli (Ott) – Ott, p. 258 (without illustrations)
2000 Chinianella carpatica (Bystrický) – Granier & Grgasovic, p. 20
(without illustration, complete synonymy-list)
M a t e r i a l : Several specimens (for thin section numbers of
illustrated material see explanations of plates).
D e s c r i p t i o n : Cylindrical specimens of this alga with
regularly arranged sterile and fertile whorls. The outer diame-
ter (D) of the thallus varies between 1.44 mm and 2.12 mm,
inner diameter (d) between 0.32 mm and 0.52 mm. Diameter
of all Iranian specimens corresponds the diameter of Ch. car-
patica (Bystrický 1967) from the Carpathians, but is moder-
ately smaller than those data given by Ott (1967) for
specimens from the Alps.
Groups of five—six sterile laterals end on the thallus surface
(Fig. 2H). Their number is given as possibly 4 by Ott (1967).
Fig. 1. Geographical position of localities southwest of the small
town of Naybandan, from which the algae of the Howz-e Khan
Member (Rhaetian) of the Nayband Formation are described. (Part
of geological map of Naybandan, Kluyver et al. 1983.)
503
TRIASSIC DASYCLADALEAN GREEN ALGAE AND SOME PROBLEMATIC ALGAE (NAYBAND FORMATION, IRAN)
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, 2011, 62, 6, 501—517
Fig. 2. Chinianella carpatica (Bystrický) and Griphoporella lutensis nov. sp. from the Howz-e Khan (Rhaetian) Member of the Nayband For-
mation south of the type locality, near the motorway service area Dig-e Rostam. Scale in all Figs. = 0.5 mm. A—I – Chinianella carpatica
(Bystrický). A – Marginal axial section showing several sterile and fertile laterals with numerous peripheral laterals (secondary laterals) end-
ing on the surface of the alga. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-9. B – Axial section through a specimen showing the main stem and numerous
fertile and sterile laterals similar to Fig. A. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-9. C – Oblique section showing the two kinds of laterals as in
Fig. A—B. The sterile branches exhibit several secondary laterals. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-24. D – Oblique section similar as Fig. C.
Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-31. E – Oblique cross section showing the fertile and sterile laterals. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-16.
F – Similar as Fig. E. thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-11. G – Oblique section of a poorly preserved specimen. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-16.
H – Oblique marginal section showing three fertile and several sterile laterals. Five sterile laterals are grouped. Thin section BSPG 2010-
XIII-24. I – Cross section showing some fertile and sterile laterals as well as numerous peripheral laterals (secondary laterals). Thin sec-
tion BSPG 2010-XIII-31. J—N – Griphoporella lutensis nov. sp. J – Oblique section similar to Fig. K. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-32.
K – Holotype. Oblique section through the thallus showing the wide central stem and the thin thallus wall pierced by numerous equally
distributed laterals. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-3. L – Oblique section through a broken specimen showing the same algal characteris-
tics as other specimens. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-33. M – Section through a broken and poorly preserved specimen. Thin section
BSPG 2010-XIII-19. N – Similar to Fig. M. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-25.
504
SENOWBARI-DARYAN, RASHIDI and SABERZADEH
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, 2011, 62, 6, 501—517
The number of laterals of sterile whorls is given 5—7 by
Bystrický (1967) in sections, but maybe up to 20 laterals ex-
tending to the surface. The diameter of fertile laterals varies
between 0.32 mm 0.60 mm. Both, the diameter of sterile and
fertile laterals on the thallus surface are with 0.040—0.080 mm
almost the same. In our material, there are 6 sporangia in each
whorl, but Ott (1967) gives their number as 7—8. The biomet-
rical data of Iranian specimens of Ch. carpatica (Bystrický) is
given in Table 1.
O c c u r r e n c e : The geographical distribution and the
stratigraphical range of Ch. carpatica are given by Granier &
Grgasovic (2000). The alga is described here for the first time
from the Upper Triassic (Rhaetian) of Iran.
Genus: Griphoporella Pia, 1915
T y p e s p e c i e s : Gyroporella curvata Gümbel, 1872.
R e m a r k s : The attribution of Griphoporella within the
dasycladales is controversial. Pia (1915, 1920) did not place
Griphoporella in any family. Following Deloffre (1988),
Berger & Kaever (1992) attributed Griphoporella to the fami-
ly Seletonellaceae (tribe: Mastoporeae Pia, 1920). Barattolo et
al. (1993) discussed the differences between Griphoporella
and other similar looking dasycladales attributing Gripho-
porella to the family Dasycladaceae, tribe Salpingoporelleae.
The family Triploporellaceae was emended by LoDuca (1977)
and this systematic is followed here.
Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel, 1872), Pia, 1915
(Fig. 4A—G, Fig. 5A—L, Fig. 6A—G, Fig. 7A—K, Fig. 8, Fig. 12)
*1872 Gyroporella curvata n. sp. – Gümbel pl. D.IV, fig. 2a—d
1915 Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel) – Pia, pl. 1, fig. 11
1988 Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel) – Sartorio & Venturini, p. 56/2
1988 Macroporella retica Zanin-Buri – Sartorio & Venturini, p. 56/3
1993 Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel) – Barattolo, De Castro &
Parente, p. 26, pl. 1—7
1997 Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel 1872) – Grgasovic, pl. 2, fig. 8,
13 (selected syn.).
2000 Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel) – Granier & Grgasovic, p. 67—70
(com. syn.)
2000 Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel, 1872) Pia, 1915. – Senowbari-
Daryan & Hamedani, p. 102, pl. 1, fig. 1, 2A, 4, 6, 7, pl. 2,
fig. 1B, 2 B, 3B, pl. 3, fig. 2B, 4, pl. 4, fig. 9
M a t e r i a l : Numerous specimens. We have illustrated nu-
merous specimens cut in different directions of the thallus to
show the strong variability of this alga.
D e s c r i p t i o n : The simple calcareous thallus of this alga is
straight or moderately curved and slightly club shaped, reach-
ing outer diameters between 2.6 mm and 4.0 mm, the inner
diameter between 1.8 mm and 3.2 mm. Two specimens with
diameters of 7.5 (Fig. 6A: type 2) and 10 mm (Fig. 12F/A) are
extremely large.
The very wide axial stem is surrounded by a thin wall com-
pared with the diameter of the alga. The thallus wall contains
wide laterals arranged in alternating verticils (whorls), recog-
nizable in sections oblique to the wall. The laterals are proxi-
mally narrow, becoming distally wider (phloiophore). They
are always closed by a thin and convex wall. In the convex
wall of some specimens very small pores are perceptible, but
unverifiable. The partial lack of the convex wall in some spec-
imens is interpreted as a possibly result of post-mortem weath-
ering. The wall between the individual laterals is proximally
relatively thick, becoming thinner in the middle part of the
walls. Because of the relatively thin wall of the large thalli,
most specimens are broken and the thallus fragments are ex-
tremely abundant in investigated thin sections.
We distinguished two types (based on variability?) of the
thalli with moderately different biometrical data. Type 1 with
Fig. 3. Chinianella carpatica (Bystrický). Two longitudinal sec-
tions and a cross section exhibiting the fertile and sterile laterals, as
well as the fine, distal laterals (drawn from specimens illustrated in
Fig. 2A—B and E).
Section
D
d
T
DS
DF
DSF
d/D
PS
KHK3
1.6
0.4
0.04–0.06
0.04
0.32
0.04–0.05
0.25
cross
KHK19
1.6
0.32
0.12
0.04
0.48
0.04
0.2
cross
KHK19
1.68
0.44
0.08–0.1
0.04
0.6
0.04–0.05
0.26
cross
KHK19
2.12 0.48
0.08
0.04
0.48–0.5
0.06–0.08 0.22 oblique
KHK19
1.8
0.52
0.08
0.04–0.06
0.6
0.06–0.08
0.28
cross
KHK19-2
1.44
0.44
0.04–0.06
0.06
0.44–0.6
0.04–0.06
0.3
oblique
KHK19-3
–
–
–
–
0.4
0.08
–
tangential
Table 1: Biometrical data of Chinianella carpatica (Bystrický) from the Rhaetian Howz-e Khan Member of the Nayband Formation, northeast
Iran. D – outer diameter of the thallus, d – diameter of the central stem, T – thickness of the wall around central stem, DS – diameter of
the sterile laterals at the base, DF – diameter of sporangia, DSF – diameter of sterile and fertile laterals ending on the surface of thallus,
d/D – ratio of central stem/outer diameter of the thallus, PS – position of section. All measurements are in mm (d/D in %).
505
TRIASSIC DASYCLADALEAN GREEN ALGAE AND SOME PROBLEMATIC ALGAE (NAYBAND FORMATION, IRAN)
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, 2011, 62, 6, 501—517
Fig. 4. A—G – Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel) type1 from the Howz-e Khan (Rhaetian) Member of the Nayband Formation south of the type
locality, near the motorway service area Dig-e Rostam. Scale in A—C and E = 1 mm; in F = 0.5 mm; in D and G = 0.3 mm. A – Longitudinal
section. The specimen shows the wide central stem and the thin wall of the thallus. In the well preserved lower part of the thallus the phloio-
phore laterals are narrow at the base (proximal) becoming wider to the periphery (distal). Outside the laterals are closed by a faulted thin wall.
Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-22. B – Longitudinal section through a broken specimen showing similar thallus wall characteristics as Fig. A.
Some broken fragments of the same alga are embedded within the sediments of the central stem showing clearly the faulted thin wall covered
the laterals on the outside. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-29. C – Oblique section showing the wide central stem and laterals with the same
characteristics as in Fig. B. Some broken fragments are embedded within the central stem. Thin section BSGP 2010-XIII-4. D – Section
through the thallus wall of a broken specimen exhibiting branches, which are distally closed by a thin and convex wall. Thin section BSGP 2010-
XIII-16. E – Longitudinal section exhibiting similar characteristics to the thallus as in Fig. A. BSGP 2010 XIII-1. F – Cross section showing
the wide central stem and the thin thallus wall with numerous laterals. The phloiophore laterals are proximally wide becoming distally wid-
er. All laterals are closed by the faulted thin wall. The walls between the individual laterals are thinner than the diameter of the laterals.
Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-26. G – Section with similar thallus wall characteristics as Fig. D. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-41.
506
SENOWBARI-DARYAN, RASHIDI and SABERZADEH
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, 2011, 62, 6, 501—517
Fig. 5. A—L – Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel) type 1 from the Howz-e Khan (Rhaetian) Member of the Nayband Formation south of the type
locality, near the motorway service area Dig-e Rostam. Scale in Figs. A—C = 1 mm, in D—L = 0.5 mm. A – Oblique section clearly showing the
shape of closed laterals of the thin thallus wall. The alternating arrangement of the laterals is clearly recognizable in the oblique section through the
wall in the lower part. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-15. B – Similar section as Fig. A. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-17. C – Longitudinal sec-
tion showing the closed laterals of the thallus wall. Laterals are proximally narrow, becoming wider at the distal end (phloiophore). Laterals are
arranged in alternating verticiles, recognizable in the oblique section through the wall in the lower part. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-13.
D – Oblique section. Some laterals are open to the outside; this is interpreted possibly as a result of post-mortem weathering. Thin section
2010-XVIII-8. E – Cross section through a broken specimen displaying the shape of distally closed laterals. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-28.
F – Cross section showing similar characteristics of the thallus as Fig. E. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-18. G – Cross section. The spec-
imens exhibit the thin faulted wall covering the laterals. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-26. H – Cross section of a thallus showing similar
characteristics as Fig. G. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-4. I – Similar to Fig. H. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-25. J – Similar to Fig. H.
Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-12. K – Similar to Fig. H. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-14. L – Oblique cross section demonstrating the
shape of the laterals. Laterals are proximally narrow, become distally wider (phloiophore). Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-34.
507
TRIASSIC DASYCLADALEAN GREEN ALGAE AND SOME PROBLEMATIC ALGAE (NAYBAND FORMATION, IRAN)
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, 2011, 62, 6, 501—517
Fig. 6. A—G – Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel) type 2 (A—B, D, F—G) and type 1 (C, E) from the Howz-e Khan (Rhaetian) Member of the
Nayband Formation south of the type locality, near the motorway service area Dig-e Rostam. Scale in Figs. A—C = 1 mm, in D—G = 0.5 mm.
A – Longitudinal section showing the thin thallus wall with slender phloiophore laterals. Several broken thallus wall fragments are embedded
within the central stem showing the shape of laterals. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-21. B – Longitudinal section showing numerous slender
phloiophore laterals arranged in alternating verticiles (recognizable in lower part of the thallus). Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-30. C – Longi-
tudinal section showing the phloiophore and distally closed laterals. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-8. D – Oblique cross section. The slender
phloiophore laterals are in part distally closed. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-6. E – Oblique cross section showing similar characteristic of
the thallus as Fig. D. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-18. F – Similar section as Fig. D. Thin sections BSPG 2010-XIII-27. G – Similar sec-
tion as Fig. E. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-15.
508
SENOWBARI-DARYAN, RASHIDI and SABERZADEH
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, 2011, 62, 6, 501—517
Fig. 7. A—K – Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel) type 2 (C—D, F, K) and type 1 (A—B, E, G—J) from the Howz-e Khan (Rhaetian) Member
of the Nayband Formation south of the type locality, near the motorway service area Dig-e Rostam. Scale in Figs. A—D and F—H = 1 mm, in
E, I—K = 0.5 mm. A – Longitudinal section of a specimen showing parts of the closed phloiophore laterals. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-17.
B – Longitudinal section showing the distally closed phloiophore laterals. Note the alternating verticiles. The walls between the laterals
are thinner than the diameter of laterals. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-40. C – Longitudinal section through a specimen showing the slen-
der phloiophore laterals open at the distal end. The thickness of the walls between the branches is about the diameter of laterals or even
thicker. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-20. D – Oblique cross section. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-19. E – Cross section. The laterals
are distally closed by a thin wall. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-2. F – Section similar as Fig. C displaying slender laterals. Thin section
BSPG 2010-XIII-18. G – Oblique longitudinal section showing distally closed laterals. Thin section BSPG-XIII-18. H – Cross section
through a specimen showing the distally closed phloiophore laterals. The fragment within the axial stem also shows some distally closed laterals.
Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-37. I – Cross section showing the distally closed phloiophore laterals. Thin section BSPG-XIII-38. J – Simi-
lar as Fig. I. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-2. K – Section similar as Fig. G. BSPG 2010-XIII-3.
509
TRIASSIC DASYCLADALEAN GREEN ALGAE AND SOME PROBLEMATIC ALGAE (NAYBAND FORMATION, IRAN)
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, 2011, 62, 6, 501—517
pear-shaped laterals (Fig. 4A—G, Fig. 5A—L, Fig. 6C,E,
Fig. 7A—B,E,G—J, Fig. 12F/A); type 2 with slender laterals
(Fig. 6A—B,D,F—G, Fig. 7C—D,F,K, Fig. 12F/B). Biometric
data of the thallus of both types are separately summarized in
Table 2. Illustrations in Fig. 8 exhibit the variability of the
alga in the investigated material. Fig. 9 shows the ratio of the
central stem the thallus diameter (d/D) of type 1 (triangle) and
type 2 (rectangle) and Fig. 10 the ratio of the thallus wall to
the outer diameter (t/D) of type 1 (triangle) and type 2 (rectan-
gle) of Griphoporella curvata.
D i s c u s s i o n : On the basis of numerous specimens from
the type locality Barattolo et al. (1993) re-described Gripho-
porella curvata (Gümbel 1872) designating the neotype and
emending the species and genus diagnosis. A complete syno-
nymy-list of the species is given by these authors and by
Granier & Grgasovic (2000). Barattolo et al. (1993) synony-
mized Macroporella retica described by Zanin Buri (1965)
from the Rhaetian of “Prealpi Lombardi”, north Italia. Con-
firming the opinion of Barattolo et al. (1993) Pugliese (1995)
re-described Macroporella retica from the Upper Triassic of
the type locality near the town of Aviatic (Lombardy, Italy).
Also those specimens, illustrated as Macroporella retica by
Ciarapica et al. (1987) were synonymized with Griphoporella
curvata (Gümbel) by Barattolo et al. (1993). The holotype of
Macroporella retica, illustrated in pl. 44/a by Zanin Buri
(1965) is different from several specimens of Griphoporella
Fig. 8. Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel). Fig. A—E (type 1) and F—H
(type 2). Drawn from specimens illustrated in Fig. 4A—B, Fig. 5A—C,
Fig. 6B and Fig. 7C and F. Scale in all Figs. is 1 mm.
Type 1
Section No:
D
d
T
PP
PD
TB
TF
Position
J-39
2.64
1.93
0.4
0.2
0.2
0.04
0.03
Cross
J-39
4.00
2.96
0.48
0.12
0.2
0.04
0.12–0.18
Longitud.
J-30
1.60 1.00 0.2–0.21
0.05–0.12
0.12–0.16 0.04 0.12
–
J-1-3
2.44
2.04
0.32
0.16
0.2
0.04
0.08
Cross
J-1-3
4.00
3.20
0.4
0.12–.16
0.2
0.04–0.06
0.06–.08
Cross
J-2-4
2.96 2.40 0.24–.28 0.08 0.16 0.04 0.04 Oblique
J-2-4
2.96 2.48 0.2–0.24 0.12
0.16
0.04 0.04–0.09 Oblique
J-14-2
2.80 2.16
0.32–0.36 0.16 0.24 0.06 0.06
Cross–oblique
J-14-2
3.20 2.48
0.28–0.32 0.16 0.28 0.04 0.08–0.12 Cross
J-18-2
3.40
2.64
0.4
0.12
0.12
0.04–0.08
0.16
Oblique
J-2-7
3.08 2.20 0.24 0.08 0.16–0.32
0.16–0.64 0.04
Cross–oblique
J-2-7
2.60
2.00
0.2
0.08–0.12
0.16–0.2
0.16–0.4
0.06–0.08
Oblique
J-2-7
2.60
1.8
0.32–0.4
0.08
0.36
0.16–0.2
0.04
Cross
J-15-1
2.08
1.64
0.24–0.4
0.16
0.2
0.08–0.4
0.04
Oblique
J-9-1
3.56 2.84 0.36 0.08–0.12 0.24 0.16 0.04
Cross
J-2-7
2.60
1.8
0.32–0.4
0.08
0.36
0.16–0.2
0.04
Cross
J-15-1
2.08
1.64
0.24–0.4
0.16
0.2
0.08–0.4
0.04
Oblique
J-9-1
3.56 2.84 0.36 0.08–0.12 0.24 0.16 0.04
Cross
Type 2
Section No:
D
d
T
PP
PD
TB
TF
Position
J-39
4.64
3.92
0.36
0.16
0.16
0.08
0.08
Cross
J-39
10.00
9.2
0.4–0.42
0.16
0.16
0.08
0.04
Cross
J-34
3.84
3.12
0.41
0.12
0.2
0.06
0.04
Oblique
J-34
2.64
2.08
0.4
0.1
0.1
0.06
0.08
Cross
J-2-4
4.00
3.36
0.32–0.36
0.16
0.2–0.24
0.04
0.04
Oblique
J-18
4.72
3.92
0.32–0.4
0.16
0.16–0.2
0.04–0.06
0.08–0.12
Oblique
J-18
3.00
2.20
0.32
0.16
0.16–0.18
0.04–0.12
0.12
Oblique
J-15-1
3.76
3.00
0.4
0.08–0.16
0.2–0.24
0.4–0.6
0.04
Longitudinal
J-10-1
3.20
2.48
0.4–0.48
0.12
0.12–0.16
0.08–0.12
0.04
Cross
J-10-1
1.64
1.16
0.24–0.28
0.16
0.16
0.04
0.04
Cross
J-3-2
3.6
3.00
0.28–0.32
0.08–0.12 0.2
0.12–0.16
0.04
Oblique
Table 2: Biometrical data of Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel). The data of both distinguished types are listed separately. D – outer diameter
of the thallus, d – inner diameter of the thallus, T – thickness of the wall, PP – proximal diameter of laterals, PD – distal diameter of laterals,
TB – thickness of the wall between the laterals, TF – thickness of the wall covered distally the laterals. All measurements are in mm.
510
SENOWBARI-DARYAN, RASHIDI and SABERZADEH
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, 2011, 62, 6, 501—517
Fig. 9. Ratio of the central stem to the thallus diameter (d/D) of
type 1 (triangle) and type 2 (rectangle) of Griphoporella curvata
(Gümbel). There are no serious differences between types 1 and 2
discussed in the text. One specimen was observed (see Fig. 12F/A)
with an outer diameter of 10 mm, much larger than all other speci-
mens. Units for all data are in mm.
Fig. 10. Ratio of the thickness of thallus wall to the thallus diameter
(t/D) of type 1 (triangle) and type 2 (rectangle) of Griphoporella
curvata (Gümbel). Units for all data are in mm.
curvata (Gümbel) illustrated by the same author in pl. 63. The
type species of Macroporella retica, illustrated by Zanin Buri
(1965) in pl. 44/a, shows the distally closed laterals in part
like in most specimen (type 1) from Iran, a characteristic,
which is not visible in specimens illustrated by Barattolo et
al. (1993). The closed laterals are also not visible in speci-
mens of Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel) illustrated by other
authors (e.g. Flügel 1981: fig. 10/E; Pugliese 1995: pl. 1,
fig. 6; Grgasovic 1997: pl. 2, fig. 8, 13). The laterals of speci-
mens from central Iran, described as Griphoporella curvata
Senowbari-Daryan & Hamedani (2000) are also distally open
and the shape of the laterals is different. The differences be-
tween our specimens are shown in Table 2 (type 1 and type 2).
In summary, based on the shape of laterals two types of
Griphoporella can be distinguished in the investigated materi-
al. As shown in Table 2, the differences of other specific data
are diffuse and do not allow us to describe them as separate
species. Because both types are united in Griphoporella cur-
vata (Gümbel) by previous authors, particularly in the synony-
my-list of Barattolo et al. (1993) and Granier & Grgasovic
(2000) we do not separate them and describe both types as
Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel).
O c c u r r e n c e : Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel) is known
from the Norian—Rhaetian of numerous localities on the world
(see Grgasovic 1997; Granier & Grgasovic 2000). It was de-
scribed from the Norian of central Iran by Senowbari-Daryan
& Hamedani (2000) and occurs extremely abundantly in the
Rhaetian Howz-e Khan Member of the Nayband Formation in
northeast Iran (this paper).
Griphoporella? sp.
(Fig. 11C,J)
M a t e r i a l : Six specimens, from which only two are illus-
trated.
D e s c r i p t i o n : The two illustrated specimens are united in
one species, but may be different taxa. The outer diameter of
the specimens illustrated in Fig. 11C is 4.6 mm; inner diame-
ter is 2.9 mm. It is surrounded by white incrustation (possibly
spongiomorphids?). The polygonal laterals are about 0.3 mm
in diameter and arranged in two rows.
The specimen, illustrated in Fig. 11J is cut in longitudinal
section reaching an outer diameter of 3.0 mm; inner diameter
2.4 mm. Compared to the first specimen the laterals are circu-
lar or oval.
Griphoporella lutensis nov. sp.
(Fig. 2J—N, Fig. 12G—H, Fig. 13)
2005 Chains of spores of diploporid dasycladales – Fürsich et al., pl. 10,
fig. 8
D e r i v a t i o n o m i n i s : Named from the Lut desert in east
Iran.
H o l o t y p e : Specimen illustrated in Fig. 2K (compare
Fig. 13).
P a r a t y p e s : All specimens in Fig. 2J,L—N, Fig. 12G—H.
L o c u s t y p i c u s : See locality 2 in Fig. 1 (it was also
found in other two localities in Fig. 1).
511
TRIASSIC DASYCLADALEAN GREEN ALGAE AND SOME PROBLEMATIC ALGAE (NAYBAND FORMATION, IRAN)
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, 2011, 62, 6, 501—517
Table 3: Biometrical data of Griphoporella lutensis nov. sp. (for abbreviations see Table 2). P – Diameter of laterals. All measurements
are in mm.
S t r a t u m t y p i c u m : Howz-e Khan Member (Rhaetian)
of the Nayband Formation.
D i a g n o s i s : Cylindrical, possibly club-shaped alga with
extremely wide central stem and thin thallus wall with modest
extension of laterals. Single laterals are distributed equally
through the thallus wall. Euspondyl arrangement of the laterals.
M a t e r i a l : At least four, more or less well preserved and
some broken specimens.
D e p o s i t o r y : See chapter localities above.
D e s c r i p t i o n : Compared to the outer or inner diameter of
the thallus, the thallus wall is very thin reaching a thickness of
0.1—0.18 mm. The outer diameter of the thallus varies be-
tween 2.02—2.85 mm, the inner diameter between 1.77 mm
and 2.62 mm. The wall contains numerous single laterals dis-
tributed equally within the wall and oriented vertically to the
wall. The diameter of laterals is about 0.036—0.075 mm. Some
of laterals are proximally or distally closed (due to the sec-
tion), other are on both ends open being significant of all later-
als. The wall between the laterals is about 0.01—0.03 mm. In
oblique sections through the thallus wall the arrangement of
the laterals seems to be of euspondyl type (Fig. 2J—L). The bi-
ometrical data of the thallus and thallus elements of G. luten-
sis nov. sp. are given in Table 3.
D i s c u s s i o n : Senowbari-Daryan & Hamedani (2000) de-
scribed the species Diplopora iranica from the Norian part of
the Nayband Formation, central Iran. Numerous coherent ga-
metangia, arranged like hoses within the central stem were
found within D. iranica. Fragments of such sporangia-hose
were mentioned first as “Mikroproblematikum 1” by Flügel &
Flügel-Kahler (1963) and later were described in detail by
Flügel (1964) as “Problematikum 4”. Such “cell-aggregates”
were also illustrated from the Norian-Rhaetian carbonates of
the Northern Calcareous Alps by Sadati (1981) as “Problema-
tikum 4” or by Wurm (1982) as “Griphoprella curvata” or
“micritic tubes” in page 274 by the same author. The dimen-
sions of the “cells” in “Problematikum 4” Flügel and other
specimens from the Alps correspond to the dimensions of the
sporangia in D. iranica and are identical to our specimens de-
scribed in this paper.
“Problematikum 4” Flügel (1964) and other specimens
from the Alps and the sporangia-hoses in D. iranica appear
dark micritic in transmitted light. As shown by Senowbari-
Daryan & Hamedani (2000) the crystal sizes of the wall are
micro-grains of about 5 µm and the mineralogy of Mg-calcite.
The alga, described above as Griphoporella lutensis nov. sp.
was never found within the central stem of other algae and
D. iranica was not found in investigated material. G. lutensis
appears light-coloured in transmitted light, indicating the cal-
cite mineralogy of the alga, different from those described by
Flügel (1964) and Senowbari-Daryan & Hamedani (2000).
Further differences are the thickness of the wall between the
individual laterals in Griphoporella lutensis. The wall be-
tween the gametangia in D. iranica is much thinner than in
Griphoporella lutensis. Also the laterals in the new alga are
proximally and distally open, the gametangia in D. iranica are
closed at both ends. These differences are against the equality
of this alga and the sporangia-hoses of D. iranica.
Diplopora cf. D. interiecta Fenninger, 1969
(Fig. 11F—G)
1969 Diplopora interiecta n. sp. – Fenninger, p. 24—25, pl. 1, fig. 1—9
M a t e r i a l : Two specimens.
D e s c r i p t i o n : Two specimens of this alga are cut in lon-
gitudinal and oblique sections showing the character and the
branching pattern of the laterals (metaspondyle) at the base
of the thallus wall. The outer diameter of the alga is 1.5—
2.9 mm; the inner diameter 1.1—2.0 mm; diameter of laterals
0.07—0.2 mm.
R e m a r k s : Diplopora is an abundant algal genus in
Triassic carbonates. Numerous specimens are known from
Permian and Triassic strata (Granier & Grgasovic 2000).
Three species of Diplopora are known from the Upper Trias-
sic of Iran: Diplopora interiecta Fenninger (1969), D. iranica
Senowbari-Daryan & Hamedani (2000), and D. phanerospora
Pia (in: Fürsich et al. 2005). The dimensions and other charac-
teristics of our species are similar to that species, described as
D. interiecta by Fenninger (1969) from the Upper Triassic
(Norian—Rhaetian) of the Golpaygan area (northwest Iran).
Similar algae to D. interiecta were also reported from the No-
rian—Rhaetian of Austria and Sicily (see synonymy-list of D.
interiecta in Granier & Grgasovic 2000).
Clypeina? sp.
(Fig. 11K)
Section No:
D
d
T
P
TB
Position of section
J-2-6
2.85
2.62
0.11
0.056–0.075
0.037
Oblique
KHK-14
2.05 1.80 0.1–0.11 0.04 0.01–0.02 Oblique
H-9
2.02
1.77
0.10–0.11
0.049
0.034
Oblique-cross
J-29
2.13
1.92
0.09–0.117
0.04–0.045
0.27
Oblique
J-2-6
–
–
0.11
0.05
0.037
Broken
J-2
–
–
0.15
0.056
0.0375
Longitudinal-broken
J-14-2
–
–
0.18
0.04
0.027
Longitudinal-broken
J-2-6
–
–
0.109
0.036–0.042
–
Oblique-broken
J-9-2
– –
0.075–0.011
0.03
0.02–0.03
Oblique-broken
J-8-2
–
–
0.09–0.1
0.03–0.04
0.028
Longitudinal-broken
J-2
– – 0.15
0.03–0.05
0.3
Longitudinal-broken
H-1
– – 0.02–0.05
0.033–0.05
Tangential
J-20
– – 0.11
0.054–0.059
0.01–0.03
Oblique-broken
512
SENOWBARI-DARYAN, RASHIDI and SABERZADEH
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, 2011, 62, 6, 501—517
Fig. 11. Dasycladales and problematic algae from the Howz-e Khan (Rhaetian) Member of the Nayband Formation south of the type locality,
near the motorway service area Dig-e Rostam. Scale in Figs. A—B, E, G—I, K—O = 0.5 mm, in Figs. C—D, F, J and P = 1 mm. A – Dasycla-
dacean alga. Longitudinal section showing the thin thallus wall and laterals, which are closed to the outside. BSPG 2010-XIII-2. B – Dasycla-
dacean alga gen. et sp. indet. 2. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-36. C – Griphoporella? sp. Oblique section through a broken specimen
showing polygonal laterals arranged in two rows. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-6. D – Dasycladacean alga. Oblique section. The individual
laterals become wider in the distal part of the thallus. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-16. E – Dasycladacean alga. Thin section BSPG
2010-XIII-12. F—G – Diplopora cf. D. interiecta. F – Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-5. G – Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-19.
H – Dasycladacean alga gen. et sp. indet 1. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-23. I – Dasycladacean alga gen. et sp. indet 2. Thin section
BSPG 2010-XIII-17. J – Griphoporella? sp. BSPG 2010-XIII-29. K – Clypeina? sp. Cross section through a re-crystallized specimen.
Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-7. L – Bacinella irregularis Radoicic. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-13. M – Thaumatoporella parvovisi-
culifera (Raineri). BSPG 2010-XIII-17. N – Lithocodium aggregatum Elliott. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-28. O – Lithocodium aggre-
gatum Elliott. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-24. P – Bacinella irregularis Radoicic. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-16.
513
TRIASSIC DASYCLADALEAN GREEN ALGAE AND SOME PROBLEMATIC ALGAE (NAYBAND FORMATION, IRAN)
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, 2011, 62, 6, 501—517
M a t e r i a l : One specimen only.
The only cross section of this species is strongly re-crystal-
lized and the detail of the alga is not ascertainable. The outer
diameter of the alga is 1.0 mm; the inner diameter 0.36 mm.
R e m a r k s : Clypeina is an abundant algal genus in Creta-
ceous deposits. From Triassic only the species Clypeina besici
is described by Pantic (1965) from the Carnian of the Dinarids
(Montenegro). Questionable Clypeina from Upper Triassic
(Norian—Rhaetian) is reported by Flügel (1979: pl. 2, fig. 9)
and by Senowbari-Daryan (1980: pl. 14, fig. 6).
Similar algae to Clypeina? sp., described above are illustrat-
ed by Bodrogi et al. (1993) as Clypeina sp. from the Lower
Cretaceous of Hungary. Nittel (2006) also illustrated from the
Middle Triassic of the Northern Calcareous Alps, Austria a
similar section identified as bryozoans. Most probably the Ira-
nian species is a new algal taxon.
Dasycladales gen. et sp. indet 1
(Fig. 11H)
M a t e r i a l : One specimen only.
D e s c r i p t i o n : The only one specimen is cut in longitudi-
nal section. The U-shaped thallus exhibits a thin wall. The dia-
meter of the thallus is about 1.6 mm. The outer surface
appears to be annulated, caused by the narrow and short later-
als in relatively wide distances.
Dasycladales gen. et sp. indet 2
(Fig. 11B, I)
M a t e r i a l : Two specimens only.
D e s c r i p t i o n : From this alga only two incomplete speci-
mens in cross section are available. The description is based
mainly on specimen illustrated in Fig. 11B.
The thick-walled thallus exhibits a thin wall at the base of
laterals. Laterals become continuously thinner to the thallus
periphery, resembling representatives of the genus Physopo-
rella. The outer diameter of alga is 1.65 mm; inner diameter
0.90 mm; wall thickness 0.82 mm.
R e m a r k s : Physoporella is an abundant algal genus in the
Permian and in Middle Triassic, particularly in the Anisian.
Only two species of Physoporella are known from the
Norian—Rhaetian: Physoporella jomdaensis Flügel & Mu
(1982) from eastern Tibet and Ph. zamparelliae Parente &
Climaco (1999) from south Italy. Most probably the Iranian
species is a new algal taxon.
Dasycladalean algae
(Fig. 11A,D—E)
In addition to the described taxa other dasycladales occur
very rare, illustrated in Fig. 11A,D—E. Specimen in A is a very
small alga exhibiting the laterals corresponding to the genus
Griphoporella. The specimen in D seems to be a representa-
tive of the genus Macroporella. The specimen in Fig. 11E is
an indet one.
Division: Chlorophyta Kützing, 1843
Family: Incertae sedis
Genus: Lithocodium Elliott, 1956
E m e n d e d d i a g n o s i s : See Schlagintweit et al. (2010).
T y p e s p e c i e s : Lithocodium aggregatum Elliott, 1956.
D i s c u s s i o n : Elliott (1956) assigned Lithocodium aggre-
gatum to codiacean algae. Lithocodium aggregatum was at-
tributed to luftusiid foraminifer by Schmid & Leinfelder
(1996). Banner et al. (1990) synonymized Bacinella irregu-
laris Radoicic (1959) and Pseudolithocodium carpaticum
Mišík (1979) with Lithocodium, attributing these to the new
subfamily Lithocodioidea within the family Codiaceae
(Siphonales, Clorophyceae). For Bacinella? sterni Radoicic
(1972) the new genus Radoicicinellopis was established by
Banner et al. (1990). Cherchi & Schroeder (2006) favour, that
Lithocodium is a calcified cyanobacterium rather than a fora-
minifer. Recently Schlagintweit et al. (2010) discussed the
systematic position of Lithocodium attributing it to “filamen-
tous-septate heterotrichale ulvophycean alga”. Assigning to
“endolithic ulvophycean alga” these authors separate Bacinella
from Lithocodium, which was synonymized by Banner et al.
(1990). With separation of Lithocodium and Bacinella the sys-
tematic classification proposed by Schlagintweit et al. (2010)
is followed here to describe the two following organisms.
?Lithocodium aggregatum Elliott, 1956
(Fig. 11N—O)
R e m a r k s : According to Schlagintweit et al. (2010) the
Triassic organisms, known as “Lithocodium aggregatum”
Elliott is excluded from Lithocodium aggregatum Elliott
(1956) by these authors. Here only the synonymy of Triassic
“Lithocodium aggregatum” is listed below. For the synonymy
of Jurassic—Cretaceous Lithocodium see Schlagintweit et al.
(2010).
Selected synonymy
*1959 Problematicum A – Ohlen, p.73, pl.10, fig.1, pl.17, fig. 3
1979 Lithocodium – Senowbari-Daryan & Schäfer, pl. 1, fig. 8
1981 Lithocodium aggregatum Elliott – Sadati, p. 206, pl. 59, fig. 8
1984 Lithocodium aggregatum Elliott – Senowbari-Daryan, p. 33—34,
pl. 10, fig. 8 (cum. syn.)
D e s c r i p t i o n : Etching the substrate (bio- or lithoclast)
Lithocodium grows as encrustation or as aggregates between
other organisms. It is characterized by hollow cavities covered
by a layer with thin-walled alveoli. A detailed description of
Lithocodium and discussion about its systematic position are
given by Banner et al. (1990), Schmid & Leinfelder (1995,
1996), Cherchi & Schroeder (2006), and by Schlagintweit et
al. (2010).
R e m a r k s : In Triassic deposits, as in Jurassic and Creta-
ceous, Lithocodium aggregatum is usually associated with
Bacinella irregularis. In the investigated material we did not
find them in association. Lithocodium with association of Ba-
cinella irregularis is, however, reported by Fürsich et al.
(2005) from the Nayband Formation of the same area.
Order: Ulotrichales
Family: Incertae sedis
Genus: Bacinella Radoicic, 1959
514
SENOWBARI-DARYAN, RASHIDI and SABERZADEH
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, 2011, 62, 6, 501—517
Fig. 12. Problematicum 1, Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel) and Griphoporella lutensis nov. sp. from the Howz-e Khan (Rhaetian) Member
of the Nayband Formation south of the type locality, near the motorway service area Dig-e Rostam. Scale in A—E = 0.2 mm, in F = 5 mm, in
G—H = 0.5 mm. A – Section through seven cohered “columns” with lateral elements. The lateral elements of individual “columns” are con-
nected to each other. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-28. B – Section through three “columns” with laterally connected elements. Thin section
BSPG 2010-XIII-28. C – Section through two “columns” with lateral elements. The lateral elements are curved upwards. Thin section BSPG
2010-XIII-38. D – Section through two “columns” with lateral elements curved upward building circular to oval cavities. A walled tube runs
internally through each “column”. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-16. E – Section through two “columns” with laterally connected elements.
Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-35. F – Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel). A – An extremely large (about 10 mm in diameter) specimen of
type 1 with short laterals; B – A species of type 2 with long, slender laterals. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-10. G – Griphoporella lutensis
nov. sp. Oblique section showing the thin wall with numerous laterals of the thallus. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-39. H – Griphoporella
lutensis nov. sp. Section through a fragment showing the shape of the laterals in the thallus wall. Thin section BSPG 2010-XIII-40.
515
TRIASSIC DASYCLADALEAN GREEN ALGAE AND SOME PROBLEMATIC ALGAE (NAYBAND FORMATION, IRAN)
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, 2011, 62, 6, 501—517
T y p e s p e c i e s : Bacinella irregularis Radoicic, 1959.
Bacinella irregularis Radoicic, 1959
(Fig. 11L,P)
Selected synonymy
*1959 Bacinella irregularis n. sp. – Radoicic, p. 89, pl. 3, fig. 1—2
1984 Bacinella irregularis Radoicic – Senowbari-Daryan, p. 38, pl. 9,
fig. 2 (with synonymy)
2005 Bacinella irregularis Radoicic – Fürsich et al., pl. 11, fig. 3
D e s c r i p t i o n : The aggregates of Bacinella occur in mic-
rite sediments forming bubble-like cavities with thin and mic-
rite walls. The outer walls and the tabulae-like elements
within the cavities are, like Thaumatoporella partly perforated
(Fig. 11L). Bacinella do not occur together with Lithocodium
in the investigated material.
R e m a r k s : Occurring in association, the separation of Li-
thocodium aggregatum and Bacinella irregularis is in most
cases not possible. They were also described as a single organ-
ism by some authors or as separate genus/species by others
(for more information see Banner et al. 1990; Schlagintweit et
al. 2010). Bacinella and Lithocodium were not found in asso-
ciation in the investigated material. Both organisms were also
reported by Fürsich et al. (2005) from the Nayband Formation.
Incertae sedis
Genus: Thaumatoporella Pia, 1927
Type species: Gyroporella parvovesiculifera Raineri, 1922.
Thaumatoporella parvovesiculifera (Raineri), 1922
(Fig. 11M)
Selected synonymy
*1922 Gyroporella parvovesiculifera n. sp. – Raineri, p. 83, pl. 13,
fig. 17—18
1927 Thaumatoporella parvovesiculifera (Raineri) – Pia, p. 69
1984 Thaumatoporella parvovesiculifera (Raineri) – Senowbari-
Daryan, p. 35—36, pl. 7, fig. 1 (cum. syn.)
2002 Thaumatoporella parvovesiculifera (Raineri) – De Castro, text-
fig. 2, pl. 1, fig. 1—11
D e s c r i p t i o n : Thaumatoporella parvovesiculifera oc-
curs, like the preceding species in micritic sediments or be-
tween the reef organisms. The fossil is characterized by well
perforated sheets of aggregates. It is a rare fossil in the inves-
tigated material.
R e m a r k s : The systematic position of Thaumatoporella
parvovesiculifera is disputed. It was attributed to dasycladales
by (Raineri 1922), solenoporacean (Elliott 1957), codiaceans
(Johnson 1966), possibly sponges (Flügel 1983). De Castro
(1990) compared Thaumatoporella with some volvocacean
(planktonic green algae) and with rivulariacean cyanophyta.
He attributed Thaumatoporella to the new family Thaumato-
porellaceae and the new order Thaumatoporellales (see also
De Castro 2002).
Problematicum 1 (shell fragment?, alga?)
(Fig. 12A—E)
M a t e r i a l : Several fragments.
D e s c r i p t i o n : The specimen illustrated in Fig. 12A
shows 7 cohered elements (“columns”) in calcite (primary
aragonite?) preservation. Other specimens illustrated in
Fig. 12 show only fragments. Each element exhibits numer-
ous spine-like to circular peripheral elements with regularly
arrangement. Some of these peripheral elements are almost
closed, building circular cavities of about 0.085 mm in dia-
meter (Fig. 12D). The specimen illustrated in Fig. 12D also
shows that these peripheral elements originate from a thin
wall (0.04 mm thick) around an axial tube with a diameter of
0.085 mm. Other specimens show that these elements are
connected laterally with others. The thickness of the individual
“columns” is about 1.85 mm; their distance varies between
0.11 mm and 0.3 mm. The distance between peripheral ele-
ments around the “columns” varies between 0.7 mm and
0.8 mm.
D i s c u s s i o n : The specimen with an axial stem and cyst-
like elements around it, illustrated in Fig. 12D shows that
this fossil resembles dasycladales. The lack of the pores or
laterals of the wall around the axial cavity does not confirm
its interpretation as dasycladales. Other specimens, particu-
larly the specimen illustrated in Fig. 12A also fail to support
this interpretation.
The cohered columns with laterally connected elements
support the interpretation of this fossil as sections through the
ripped shell of juvenile bivalves, brachiopods or ostracods.
The sections could be oriented parallel to fragments of shell.
The axial cavity in Fig. 12C, however, does not support the in-
terpretation of this fossil as shell fragments. Another interpre-
tation could be the aptychus of cephalopods. We describe it
here as “Problematicum 1”, because ambiguous characteris-
tics make the exact interpretation of this fossil impossible.
Fig. 13. Griphoporella lutensis nov. sp. (Holotype). The specimen
shows extremely thin wall, compared with the thick axial stem
(drawn from Fig. 2K).
¾
516
SENOWBARI-DARYAN, RASHIDI and SABERZADEH
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, 2011, 62, 6, 501—517
Acknowledgments: The fieldwork was conducted by
Koorosh Rashidi and Behnam Saberzadeh as part of a master
degree from the “Islamic Azad University of Zarand Branch,
Iran”. Limited financial support came from the “Sonderfonds
für wissenschaftliche Arbeiten an der Universität Erlangen-
Nürnberg” to B. Senowbari-Daryan. We thank the Ministry of
Environment Protection in Teheran and Yazd, Mr. H. Akbari
for permission to conduct fieldwork. Our thanks are addressed
to Rowan Martinale (Los Angeles) for improvements of the
English. We thank I.I. Bucur (Cluj-Napoca) and F. Barattolo
(Napoli), whose very helpful comments as the journal review-
ers improved the manuscript.
References
Banner F.T., Finch E.M. & Simmons M.D. 1990: On Lithocodium
Elliott (calcareous algae): Its paleobiological and stratigraphical
significance. J. Micropaleont. 9, 21—36.
Barattolo F., De Castro P. & Parente M. 1993: Some remarks on
Griphoporella curvata (Gümbel 1872) Pia, 1915, dasycladacean
green alga from the Upper Triassic. In: Barattolo F., De Castro
P. & Parente M. (Eds.): Studies on fossil benthic algae. Boll.
Soc. Paleont. Ital., Spec. Vol. 1, 23—45.
Bassoullet J.-P., Bernier P., Deloffre R., Génot P., Jaffrezo M. & Va-
chard D. 1979: Essai de classification des Dasycladales in tribus.
Bull. Centres Rech. Explor.-Prod. Elf-Aquitaine 3, 2, 429—442.
Berger S. & Kaever M. 1992: Dasycladales. An illustrated mono-
graph of a fascinating algal order. Georg Thieme Verlag Stut-
tgart, New York, 1—247, 565 Illustr., 23 Tab.
Bodrogi I., Conrad M.A. & Lobitzer H. 1993: Lower Cretaceous
Dasycladales from the Villány zone, Southwest Hungary. Bio-
geographical significance. In: Barattolo F., De Castro P. &
Parente M. (Eds.): Studies on fossil benthic algae. Boll. Soc. Pa-
leont. Ital., Spec. Vol. 1, 59—68.
Brönnimann P., Zaninetti L., Moshtaghian A. & Huber H. 1974: For-
aminifera and microfacies of the Triassic Espahk Formation,
Tabas area, east central Iran. Riv. Ital. Paleont. 80, 1, 1—48.
Bucur I.I. 1999: Stratigraphic significance of some skeletal algae
(Dasycladales, Caulerpales) of the Phanerozoic. In: Farinacci A.
& Lord A.R. (Eds.): Depositional episodes and bioevents.
Palaeopelagos Spec. Publ. 2, 53—104.
Bystrický J. 1967 (1968): Die obertriadischen Dasycladaceen der
Westkarpaten. Geol. Sbor. Geol. Carpath. 18, 2, 285—309.
Cherchi A. & Schroeder R. 2006: Remarks on the systematic position
of Lithocodium Elliott, a problematic microorganism from the
Mesozoic carbonate platforms of the Tethyan realm. Facies 52,
435—440.
Ciarapica G., Cirilli S., Passari L., Trincianti E. & Zaninetti L.
1987: “Anidriti di Burano” et “Formation du Monte Cetona”
(Nouvelle Formation), Biostratigraphie de deux series-types du
Trias superieur dans L’Apennin Septentrional. Rev. Paléobiol.
2, 341—409.
De Castro P. 1990: Thaumatoporelle: Conoscenze attuali e approc-
cio all’interpretazione. Boll. Soc. Paleont. Ital. 29, 2, 179—206
(in Italian).
De Castro P. 2002: Thaumatoporella parvovesiculifera (Raineri):
typification, age and historical background (Senonian, Sorrento
Peninsula – southern Italy). Boll. Soc. Paleont. Ital. 41, 2—3,
121—129.
Deloffre R. 1988: Nouvelle taxonomie des algues dasycladales: Bull.
Centres Rech. Explor.-Prod. Elf-Aquitaine 12, 1, 165—217.
Elliott G.F. 1956: Further records of fossil calcareous algae from
the Middle East. Micropaleontology 2, 327—334.
Elliott G.F. 1957: New calcareous algae from the Arabian peninsula.
Micropaleontology 4 4, 419—428.
Fenninger A. 1969: Ein Beitrag zur Flora und Fauna im Raum von
Golpayan (Iran). Verh. Geol. Bundesanst. 1, 22—32.
Flügel E. 1964: Mikroproblematika aus den rhätischen Riffkalken der
Nordalpen. Paläont. Z. 38, 1/2, 74—87.
Flügel E. 1975: Kalkalgen aus Riffkomplexen der alpin-mediterranen
Obertrias. Verh. Geol. Bundesanst. Wien 1974, 297—346.
Flügel E. 1979: Paleoecology and microfacies of Permian, Triassic
and Jurassic algal communities of platform and reef carbonates
from the Alps. Bull. Centres Rech. Explor.-Prod. Elf-Aquitaine
3, 2, 569—587.
Flügel E. 1981: Paleoecology and facies of Upper Triassic reefs in the
Northern Calcareous Alps. In: Toomey D.F. (Ed.): European
fossil reef models. SEPM, Spec. Publ. 30, 291—359.
Flügel E. 1983: Mikrofazies der Pantokrator-Kalke (Lias) von Korfu,
Griechenland. Facies 8, 263—300.
Flügel E. 1985: Diversity and environments of Permian, Triassic and
Jurassic algae. In: Toomey D.F. & Nitecki M.H. (Eds.): Paleo-
algology. Springer, Heidelberg, New York, 344—351.
Flügel E. 1991: Triassic and Jurassic marine calcareous algae: A criti-
cal review. In: Riding R. (Ed.): Calcareous algae and stromato-
lites. Springer, 481—503.
Flügel E. & Flügel-Kahler E. 1963: Mikrofazielle und geochemische
Gliederung eines obertriadischen Riffes der nördlichen Kalkal-
pen (Sauwand bei Gußwerk, Steiermark, Österreich). Mitt. Mus.
Bergbau, Geol. Tech. Landesmus. “Joanneum” 24, 1—128.
Flügel E. & Mu X. 1982: Upper Triassic Dasycladaceae from Eastern
Tibet. Facies 6, 59—74.
Fürsich T.F., Hautmann M., Senowbari-Daryan B. & Seyed-Emami
K. 2005: The Upper Triassic Nayband and Darkuh formations of
east-central Iran: Stratigraphy, facies patterns and biota of ex-
tensional basins on an accreted terrane. Beringeria 35, 53—134.
Gollesstaneh A. 1979: The stratigraphic distribution of fossil calcare-
ous Algae in southern Iran. Bull. Centres Rech. Explor.-Prod.
Elf-Aquitaine 3, 2, 619—624.
Granier B. & Deloffre R. 1993: Inventaire Critique des Algues
Dasycladales Fossiles. II
o
Partie – les Algues Dasycladales du
Jurassic et du Cretace. Rev. Paléobiologie 12, 1, 19—65.
Granier B.R.C. & Grgasovic T. 2000: Les Algues Dasycladales du Per-
mien et du Trias. Nouvelle tentative d’inventaire bibliographique,
géographique et stratigraphique. Geol. Croatica 53, 1, 1—197.
Granier B., Masse J.-P. & Berthou P.-Y. 1994: Heteroporella lepida
PRATURLON, 1967, revisited (followed by taxonomic notes on
the so-called “Heteroporella” species). In: Piller W.E. (Ed.):
Proceedings of the International Symposium and Field-Meeting
“Alpine Algae’93”. Beitr. Paläont. 19, 129—141.
Grgasovic T. 1997: Upper Triassic biostratigraphy and algae from
Žumberak (Croatia). Geol. Croatica 50, 2, 201—214.
Gümbel C.W. 1872: Die sogenannten Nulliporen (Lithothamnium
und Dactylopora) und ihre Betheiligung an der Zusammenset-
zung der Kalkgesteine. Zweiter Theil. Die Nulliporen des Thier-
reiches (Dactyloporideae) nebst Nachtrag zu ersten Theile. Abh.
König. Bayer. Akad., Nath. Naturwiss. Kl., Abh. 1, 231—290.
Johnson J.H. 1966: Tertiary red algae from Borneo. Bull. Brit. Mus.
Nat. Hist. 2, 6, 257—280.
Kluyver H., Triw R., Chance P., Johns G. & Meixner H. 1983: Ex-
planatory text of the Naybandan Quadrangle map. 1 : 250,000.
Geol. Serv. Iran, Rept. No. 18, 143. P., 6 pls. 38 Figs., Tehran.
Kützing F.T. 1843: Phycologia Generalis oder Anatomie. Physiologie
und Systemkunde der Tange. F.A. Brockhaus, Leipzig, 311—313.
Lebouché M.C. & Lemoine M. 1963: Dasycladacées nouvelles du
Lias calcaire (Lotharingien) du Languedoc méditerranéen. Rev.
Micropaléont. 6, 2, 89—101.
LoDuca S.T. 1977: The green alga Chaetocladus (Dasycladales). J.
Paleontology 71, 5, 940—949.
517
TRIASSIC DASYCLADALEAN GREEN ALGAE AND SOME PROBLEMATIC ALGAE (NAYBAND FORMATION, IRAN)
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA
GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, 2011, 62, 6, 501—517
Mišík M. 1979: Jurassic and Cretaceous algae (Dasycladales except-
ed) from the West Carpathians. Bull. Centres Rech. Explor.-
Prod. Elf-Aquitaine 3, 2, 705—712.
Nittel P. 2006: Beiträge zur Stratigraphie und Mikropaläontologie der
Mitteltrias der Innsbrucker Nordkette (Nördliche Kalkalpen,
Austria). Geo. Alpine 3, 93—145.
Ohlen H.R. 1959: The Steinplatte reef complex of the Alpine Triassic
(Rhaetian) of Austria. Unpubl. Ph.D. Thesis, Univ. Prinsten,
Prinston, 1—123, 20 pl.
Ott E. 1967: Dasycladaceen (Kalkalgen) aus der nordalpinen Ober-
trias. Mitt. Bayer. Staatssamml. Paläont. Hist. Geol. 7, 205—226.
Ott E. 1968: Zur Nomenklatur obertriadischer Kalkalgen, besonders
der Gattungen Heteroporella Praturlon und Poikiloporella Pia
(Dasycladaceae). Mitt. Bayer. Staatssamml. Paläont. Hist. Geol.
8, 253—262.
Ott E. 1972: Zur Kalkalgen-Stratigraphie der Alpinen Trias. Mitt.
Gesell. Geol. Bergbaustud. 21, 455—464.
Pantić S. 1965: Clypeina besici sp. nov. iz Trijaskih sedimenata
Spoljasnjih Dinarida. [Clypeina besici sp. nov. des sédiments
triassiques des Dinarides externes]. Geoloski Glasnik=Bulletin
Géologique, 4, 133—141 (in Croatian).
Parente M. & Climaco A. 1999: Dasycladacean green algae from the
Upper Triassic of Mt. Rotonda (Verbicaro Unit, Calabria-Luca-
nia border, Southern Italy). Facies 41, 159—182.
Pia J. von 1915: Griphoporella curvata Gümb. sp. In: Spitz A. &
Dyhrenfurth G. (Eds.): Monographie der Engardiner Dolomiten
zwischen Schuls, Scanfs und dem Stilfserjoch. Beitr. Geol.
Karte der Schweiz, N.F., 44, 62.
Pia J. von 1920: Die siphoneae verticillatae von Karbon bis zur
Kreide. Abh. Zool. Bot. Gesell. Wien 11, 2, 1—263.
Pia J. 1927: I. Abteilung: Thallophyta. In: Hirmer M. (Ed.): Handbuch
der Paläobotanik. Bd. Odenburg, München, Berlin 1, 31—136.
Praturlon A. 1967: Algal assemblages from Lias to Paleocene in
Southern Latium-Abruzzi: a review. Boll. Soc. Geol. Ital. 85,
167—194.
Pugliese A. 1995: Some observations on Macroporella retica Zanin
Buri 1965, dasycladacean green alga from Upper Triassic. Riv.
Ital. Paleont. Stratigr. 100, 4, 537—550.
Radoicic R. 1959: Nekoliko problematičnih mikrofosila iz dinarske
Krede. [Some problematic microfossils from the Dinarian Cre-
taceous.] Bull. Ser. Géol. Géophys. Serbie 17, 87—92.
Radoicic R. 1972: Bacinella? sterni nov. sp. (Codiaceae?) from the
Cenomanian of the Environs of Orahovac Metohija. Bull. Sci.
Conseil. Acad. Sci. Arts Yougoslavie, A 17, 8, 228—229.
Raineri R. 1922: Alghe sifonee fossil della Libia. Att. Soc. Ital. Sci.
Nat., Milano 61, 72—86.
Sadati S.M. 1981: Die Hohe Wand: Ein obertriadisches Lagunen-
Riff aus Ostende der Nördlichen Kalkalpen (Niederösterreich).
Facies 5, 191—264.
Sartorio D. & Venturini S. 1988: Southern Tethys biofacies. Agip-
Publ., 1—235.
Schlagintweit F., Bover-Arnal T. & Salas R. 2010: New insights into
Lithocodium aggregatum Elliott 1956 and Bacinella irregularis
Radoicic 1959 (Late Jurassic—Lower Cretaceous): two ulvo-
phycean green algae (?Order Ulotrichales) with a heteromorphic
life cycle (epilithic/euendolithic). Facies 56, 509—547.
Schmid D.U. & Leinfelder R.R. 1995: Lithocodium aggregatum El-
liott n’est pas une algue mais un foraminifère encroutant com-
mensalisé par le foraminifère Troglotella incrustans Werneli et
Fookes. C.R. Séanc Acad. Sci. (IIa) 320, 531—538.
Schmid D.U. & Leinfelder R.R. 1996: The Jurassic Lithocodium ag-
gregatum—Troglotella incrustans foraminiferal consortium.
Palaeontology 39, 21—52.
Senowbari-Daryan B. 1980: Fazielle und paläontologische Untersu-
chungen in oberrhätischen Riffen (Feichtenstein- und Gruberriff
bei Hintersee, Salzburg, Nördliche Kalkalpen). Facies 3, 1—237.
Senowbari-Daryan B. 1984: Mikroproblematika aus den obertriadis-
chen Riffkalken von Sizilien. Münster. Forsch. Geol. Paläont.
61, 1—81.
Senowbari-Daryan B. 2003: Micropaleontology of Limestone Beds
within the Shotori Dolomite (Triassic) of Kuh-e Nayband, Tabas
Area, East-Central Iran. Facies 48, 115—126.
Senowbari-Daryan B. & Hamedani A. 2000: Obertiadische (Nor)
Dasycladaceen aus der Nayband-Formation vom Zentraliran.
Rev. Paléobiologie 19, 1, 97—121.
Senowbari-Daryan B. & Majidifard M.R. 2003: A Triassic “problem-
atic microfossil” revealed: Probolocuspis espahkensis Brönni-
mann, Zanintetti, Moshtaghian and Huber 1974 is attributed to
the Dasycladacean Algae. Facies 48, 107—114.
Senowbari-Daryan B. & Schäfer P. 1979: Distributional patterns of
calcareous algae within Upper Triassic patch reef structures of
the Northern Calcareous Alps (Salzburg). Bull. Centres. Rech.
Explor.-Prod. Elf-Aquitaine 3, 2, 811—820.
Wurm D. 1982: Mikrofazies, Paläontologie und Palökologie der
Dachsteinriffkalke (Nor) des Gosaukammes, Österreich. Facies
6, 203—296.
Zanin Buri C. 1965: Il Trias in Lombardia. XIII. Le Alghe calcaree
delle Prealpi Lombarde. Riv. Ital. Paleont. 71, 2, 449—544.