GEOLOGICA CARPATHICA, FEBRUARY 2007, 58, 1, 41—52
www.geologicacarpathica.sk
Biostratigraphy and paleoenvironmental interpretation of
the Middle Miocene submarine fan in the Adana Basin
(southern Turkey)
HURùYE DEMùRCAN
1
and AY EGÜL YILDIZ
2
1
General Directorate of Mineral Research and Exploration, Natural History Museum, 06520 Balgat, Ankara, Turkey;
huriyedemircan@yahoo.com
2
Aksaray University, Engineering Faculty, Department of Geological Engineering, 68100 Aksaray, Turkey; ayildiz@nigde.edu.tr
(Manuscript received November 18, 2005; accepted in revised form June 19, 2006)
Abstract: The turbiditic Cingöz Formation of the Karaisah-Çatalan-Eûner region, Adana Basin, southern Turkey was
studied in detail in two sections based on planktonic foraminifers, calcareous nannofossils and trace fossils. The Middle
Miocene (Langhian—Serravalian) age of the sediments is supported by the Praeorbulina glomerosa curva and Orbulina
suturalis planktonic foraminiferal Zones and by standard nannoplankton Zones NN5 Sphenolithus heteromorphus and
NN6 Discoaster exilis. Moreover, 24 ichnotaxa were identified and attributed to the Skolithos-Cruziana, mixed (Skolithos-
Cruziana and Nereites), and Nereites ichnofacies. Fossil assemblages indicate eutrophic and oligotrophic conditions. In the
Langhian, the distribution and percentage abundances of temperature sensitive planktonic taxa including Globigerina
falconensis reflect temperate to cold surface waters in the depositional area of the western and eastern fans of Cingöz
Formation. In Serravalian, higher numbers of warm-water prefering taxa indicate the rise in temperature in the western fan.
Key words: Middle Miocene, southern Turkey, biostratigraphy, paleoenvironmental interpretation, calcareous
nannoplankton, planktonic foraminifers, trace fossils, ichnofacies.
Introduction
The Cingöz submarine fan system is located approxi-
mately fifty km north of Adana in 1 : 100,000 Kozan N34
Sheet in the northern part of the Adana Basin (Fig. 1).
The following studies on the studied region and closed
areas have been published: Schmidt (1961), Özgül et al.
(1972, 1973), Yeti & Demirkol (1984) studies about the
stratigraphic properties of the area; Görür (1980), Erten
(1983), Yalçôn & Görür (1984), Yeti et al. (1986),
Gökçen et al. (1987), Naz & Çuhadar (1988), Ünlügenç
et al. (1993), Gürbüz (1998) studies about the sedimen-
Fig. 1. Geological sketch map and the position of the investigated sections (after Gürbüz 1993 modified).
42
DEMùRCAN and YILDIZ
tology of the area; Nazik & Toker (1986), Toker & Yôldôz
(1991), Ünlügenç &
afak (1992), Nazik & Gürbüz
(1992), Toker et al. (1996), Akça et al. (1998), Yôldôz et al.
(2003) studies about the paleontology; Uchman & Demir-
can (1999a,b), Uchman et al. (2002), Demircan & Toker
(2003, 2004) dealt with trace fossils; Özgül (1976), en-
gör et al. (1985), Gökçen et al. (1988) studies concentrated
on the plate tectonic evolution of the area and vicinity
while Ketin (1966) and Ayhan (1978) studies concentrat-
ed on the general geology.
The purpose of this study is to present the planktonic
foraminiferal and calcareous nannoplankton biostratigra-
phy of the Cingöz Formation, to evaluate depositional
environments on the basis of trace fossil assemblages,
and to determine changes in paleotemperature of the sea-
surface water in the region during the Middle Miocene
based on abundance and distribution of temperature-sensi-
tive planktonic foraminiferal and calcareous nannoplank-
ton species.
Material and method
The material for this study comprised 30 samples col-
lected from two sections – Kalaycôlar (western fan) and
Ku çusofulu (eastern fan) (Fig. 1). The numbers of speci-
mens of different species of planktonic foraminifers in
100 g of washed sample were recorded as abundant, 60—100
specimens; common, 30—60 specimens; few, 10—30 speci-
mens; and rare 1—10 specimens. For the analysis of calcar-
eous nannoplankton, smear slides were prepared from raw
(untreated) samples. No specific techniques were applied
to clean or concentrate the biogenic fraction, the aim be-
ing to maintain the original composition of the nannofos-
sil assemblages. Smear slides were examined under an
Ortholux polarizing microscope using an oil-immersion
objective of
100. Nannofossil abundances were estimat-
ed using the scheme of Wei (1988). Based on this method,
one or more specimens of a taxon in each field of view was
abundant, one specimen of a taxon in 2—10 fields of view
was common, one specimen of a taxon in 11—50 fields of
view was nominated as a few, and one specimen of a taxon
per 51—200 fields of view was accepted as rare.
In this paper the planktonic foraminiferal zonations of
Jenkins (1985) (Southern mid-latitude), Iaccarino (1985)
(Mediterranean), Krasheninnikov & Kaleda (1994) (South-
ern Cyprus), and Berggren et al. (1995) (Subtropical) and
the calcareous nannoplankton zones of Martini (1971)
and Perch-Nielsen (1985) were used for biostratigraphic
interpretations. In addition, the abundance (%) and distri-
bution of temperature-sensitive planktonic foraminiferal
and calcareous nannoplankton species in each sample
were determined for the next paleoenvironmental interpre-
tations.
Trace fossil studies were concentrated on the various
lithologies represented in the two sections. Trace fossils in-
vestigations were carried out both on bedding and parting
surfaces of sections and photographed when necessary. Ich-
nofacies interpretation was done by Seilacher (1967).
Geological setting and sedimentology of the Cingöz
Formation
Two major sedimentary basins (Antalya and Çukurova)
existed in the Late Cenozoic epoch in the southern Tur-
key (Kelling et al. 1987). The Çukurova Basin Complex
comprises the Adana and Iskenderun Sub-Basins separated
by the Misis Structural High Complex, which is bounded
by the Ecemi fault in the west, the Tauride Orogenic Belt
in the north and the Amanos Mountains in the east. In the
study area, Yeti & Demirkol (1986), and Gürbüz &
Kelling (1991), have undertaken sedimentological inves-
tigation of the Cingöz Formation. These authors conclud-
ed that the formation was deposited in a basin plain and
built by distal and proximal portions of submarine fans.
The deep marine turbiditic sandstone systems of Middle
Miocene age were formed in the northern part of the
Adana Basin as two (western and eastern) deep-sea fans.
The western fan derived from the northwest, whereas the
eastern fan was supplied from the north (Fig. 1). These are
small, ‘classical’, sand-rich submarine fans as defined by
Mutti (1985) and Mutti & Normak (1987).
Western fan
The western fan consists of two megacycles: lower se-
quence and upper lobe-dominated succession dominated
by coarse- to fine-grained sandstone, upwards gradually
passing into the outer fan/basin plain sediment. The lobe
and channel deposits are attached physically, both lateral-
ly and vertically. No clear distinction between the lower,
middle and upper fan elements are observed in the field
because of the attached geometry. The maximum thick-
ness of the fan is around 1500 m and corresponds well to
the low efficiency or type II turbidite system sensu Mutti
(1985) (Gürbüz 1993).
Eastern fan
The eastern submarine fan system was initiated by the
incision of individual proximal fan channels that were
probably physically linked to major channels cut into
shallow marine sediments to the north, permitting the ‘by
passing’ of coarse sediments through the mixed carbonate-
siliciclastic marginal facies belt. The lower part of this
body starts with isolated channels and is less conglomerat-
ic than the western body, with maximum clast sizes
around 60 cm. The thickness of this basal sequence is
around 500 m. The second phase of this eastern submarine
fan starts with a sequence of small isolated channels.
These are followed by a succession of prograding lobe-
dominated mid-fan cycles with thick, coarsening and
thickening upward cycles of sandstone beds. Thin-bedded
sandstone beds characterize the upper part of the eastern
fan sequence and shale intercalations belong to the lower
fan/basin environment. The channels and the lobes in the
lower part of phase 2 sequences are detached physically,
but the overlying lobes are generally mutually attached.
The eastern fan is more complex, laterally extensive and
43
BIOSTRATIGRAPHY OF THE MIOCENE SUBMARINE FAN (SOUTHERN TURKEY)
thicker (approximately 3000 m maximum) than
the western body (Gürbüz 1993).
Results
Sediments of the Kalaycôlar and Ku çusofulu
sections (see Fig. 1), provided rare but well pre-
served tests of planktonic foraminifers and medi-
um well preserved calcareous nannofossils. The
foraminiferal assemblages are composed of 11
species of 6 genera, and the nannofossil associa-
tions are composed of 27 species of 10 genera.
Some taxa and abundance differences were re-
corded in both sections.
Kalayc
ôôôôô lar section, western fan of the Cingöz
Formation
Foraminifers (Fig. 3)
The lower part of the section (samples 1—5,
Fig. 2) is characterized by abundances of species
Praeorbulina glomerosa curva, Globigerinoides
bisphericus, G. trilobus, and Globoquadrina
dehiscens. Tests of Globigerina falconensis
form 2—6 % of the assemblage. In the upper part
of the section (samples 6—14) specimens of Orbu-
lina suturalis and O. bilobata were recorded ac-
companied by higher numbers of Globigerinoides
trilobus, Globoquadrina altispira conica, and G.
dehiscens. The abundance of Globigerina falcon-
ensis falls, forming about 1—2 % of assemblage.
Specimens of P. glomerosa curva have not been
already recorded (see Fig. 2).
Calcareous nannoplankton (Fig. 4)
Samples 1—7 (see Fig. 2) contain rare Spheno-
lithus heteromorphus and higher numbers of Coc-
colithus miopelagicus and Sphenolithus abies.
The upper part of the section (samples 8—14) is
characterized by abundance of Reticulofenestra
pseudoumbilica (recorded first in sample No. 8)
and by higher numbers of Discoaster aulakos, D.
variabilis and Coccolithus miopelagicus (Fig. 2).
Concerning sphenoliths, S. abies occurs up to the
sample No. 9 and S. heteromorphus is already ab-
sent in this interval. Rare specimens of Braaru-
dosphaera bigelowii were observed through the
whole profile.
Ku çusofulu section, eastern fan of the Cingöz
Formation
Foraminifers (Fig. 3)
Lower part of section (samples 1—7, Fig. 5) con-
tained abundant specimens of Praeorbulina glome-
Fig. 2.
Kalayc
ôlar
section,
western
fan
of
the
Cingöz
F
ormation.
Distribution
of
p
lanktonic
foraminifers,
calcareous
n
annofossils
and
trace
fossils
and
their
biostratigraphic
interpretation
including
percentage
of
Globigerina
falconensis
and
temperature
sensitive
nannoplankton
taxa.
44
DEMùRCAN and YILDIZ
rosa curva, Globigerinoides bisphericus, G. trilobus, and
Globoquadrina dehiscens. The upper part of the section
(samples 8—16) is characterized by the occurrence of Orbu-
lina suturalis and O. bilobata and by higher numbers of
Globigerinoides trilobus, Globoquadrina altispira conica,
and G. dehiscens. Species P. glomerosa curva has not been
found here. Abundance of Globigerina falconensis varies
between 2—6 % during the whole section (see Fig. 5).
Calcareous nannoplankton (Fig. 4)
The lower part of the fan (samples 1—10) is characterized
by the presence of Sphenolithus heteromorphus and S.
abies and by high numbers of Coccolithus miopelagicus,
Reticulofenestra pseudoumbilica and Helicosphaera phil-
ippinensis. In the overlying strata (samples No. 11—16) the
occurrence of other taxa was recorded, such as Dictyococ-
cites productus, Coronocylus nitescens, Helicosphaera
orientalis, and others (see Fig. 5). The assemblages con-
tain abundant specimens of Coccolithus miopelagicus
and Reticulofenestra pseudoumbilica. The stratigraphical-
ly important species Sphenolithus heteromorphus and S.
abies have not been recorded. Rare specimens of Braaru-
dosphaera bigelowii were observed through the whole
profile.
Trace fossils
Twenty-four ichnotaxa have been recognized in the in-
vestigated area. Trace fossils have been observed on bed-
ding and on parting surfaces and in vertical sections. The
following trace fossil assemblages were determined in
the Cingöz Formation western fan – from the lower part
of the section to the top: Ophiomorpha isp., Thalassi-
noides isp., Skolithos isp., Chondrites isp., Scolicia isp.,
Planolites isp., Scolicia vertebralis, Phycodes isp., Zoo-
phycos isp., Capodistria vettersi, Halopoa annulata,
Helminthopsis isp., and Cosmorhaphe sinuosa. In the
lower part of the eastern fan to the top: Ophiomorpha
isp., Ophiomorpha annulata, Thalassinoides isp., Ha-
lopoa annulata, Lophoctenium isp., Phymatoderma isp.,
Nereites isp., Nereites irregularis, Paleodictyon isp., Pa-
leodictyon delicatulum, and Paleodictyon majus. Distri-
bution of most of the described trace fossils does not
show any distinct rules. Only, Scolicia vertebralis and
Echinospira isp., display a tendency to occur in the
thicker beds. Ophiomorpha and Thalassinoides isp. only
occur in thicker beds. The remaining ichnotaxa are sepa-
rated more or less in thinner beds. The described trace
fossil assemblage is dominated by ichnotaxa of the Nere-
ites ichnofacies, represented by meandering pascichnia
(Nereites, Scolicia) and different graphoglyptids (e.g.
Paleodictyon isp., Desmograpton isp., Cosmorhaphe
isp., Helminthorhaphe isp.). Stationary fodichnia (Echi-
nospira isp.) and ?chemichnia/fodichnia (Chondrites
isp.) also occur there. ‘Shallow-water’ vertical forms
(horn-like form and Ophiomorpha isp.) typical of the
Skolithos ichnofacies, and Thalassinoides, which is the
most characteristic of the Cruziana ichnofacies, are
present there (Figs. 2, 5, 8, 9).
Fig. 3. a – Globigerinoides bisphericus, Kalaycôlar section, Sample KC-2; b – Globigerinoides trilobus, Ku çusofulu section, Sample
KS-4; c – Globigerinoides trilobus, Ku çusofulu section, Sample KS-16; d – Praeorbulina glomerosa curva, Ku çusofulu section,
Sample KS-3; e – Orbulina suturalis, Ku çusofulu section, Sample KS-10; f – Globoquadrina dehiscens, Kalaycôlar section, Sample KC-5;
g – Globoquadrina dehiscens, Kalaycôlar section, Sample KC-3; h – Globigerina woodi connecta, Kalaycôlar section, Sample KC-5.
45
BIOSTRATIGRAPHY OF THE MIOCENE SUBMARINE FAN (SOUTHERN TURKEY)
Fig. 4. a – Braarudosphaera bigelowii, Ku çusofulu section, Sample no. KS.4
4000; b – Braarudosphaera bigelowii, Ku çusofulu
section, Sample no. KS.2 4000; c – Coccolithus miopelagicus, Ku çusofulu section, Sample no. KS.2 2000; d – Coccolithus pelagi-
cus, Ku çusofulu section, Sample no. KS.4 2000; e – Dictyococcites productus, Ku çusofulu section, Sample no. KS.12 2000; f – Dis-
coaster aulakos, Kalaycôlar section, Sample no. KC.12 1350; g – Discoaster variabilis, Kalaycôlar section, Sample no. KC.12 2000;
h – Discoaster variabilis, Kalaycôlar section, Sample no. KC.14 2000; i – Helicosphaera intermedia, Ku çusofulu section, Sample no.
KS.13 1500; j – Helicosphaera kamptneri, Kalaycôlar section, Sample no. KC.10 3000; k – Helicosphaera kamptneri, Kalaycôlar sec-
tion, Sample no. KC.9 2250; l – Helicosphaera orientalis, Ku çusofulu section, Sample no. KS.13 2500; m – Helicosphaera orien-
talis, Ku çusofulu section, Sample no. KS.12 2500; n – Helicosphaera sellii, Ku çusofulu section, Sample no. KS.4 1500; o – Heli-
cosphaera sellii, Ku çusofulu section, Sample no. KS.12 1500; p – Pontosphaera sp., Ku çusofulu section, Sample no. KS.13 1500;
r – Pontosphaera sp., Ku çusofulu section, Sample no. KS.11 1500; s – Pontosphaera japonica, Kalaycôlar section, Sample no. KC.11
1150; t – Pontosphaera multipora, Ku çusofulu section, Sample no. KS.12 1750; u – Reticulofenestra minutula, Ku çusofulu sec-
tion, Sample no. KS.12 2000; v – Reticulofenestra pseudoumbilica, Ku çusofulu section, Sample no. KS.11 2500; y – Reticulofenes-
tra pseudoumbilica, Ku çusofulu section, Sample no. KS.13 3000; z – Sphenolithus conicus, Ku çusofulu section, Sample no. KS.12
1600; x – Sphenolithus heteromorphus, Ku çusofulu section, Sample no. KS.3 1700.
46
DEMùRCAN and YILDIZ
Fig.
5
Kuçusofulu
section,
eastern
fan
of
the
Cingöz
Formation.
Dist
ribution
of
planktonic
foraminifers,
calcareous
nannofossils
an
d
trace
fossils
and
their
biostratigraphic
interpretation
in-
cluding
percentage
of
Globigerina
falconensis
and
temperature
sensitive
nannoplankton
taxa.
Biostratigraphy
According to the presence of the for-
aminiferal species Praeorbulina glom-
erosa curva, the sediments from the
localities Kalaycôlar, western fan (sam-
ples 1—5,
Fig. 2)
and
Ku çusofulu,
eastern fan (samples 1—7, Fig. 5) are
correlated
with
Zone
Praeorbulina
glomerosa curva (sensu Jenkins 1985;
Iaccarino
1985;
Krasheninnikov
&
Kaleda 1994; Berggren et al. 1995)
(Fig. 6). This interval is also defined as
the Praeorbulina glomerosa s.s. Zone
in subtropical areas (Berggren et al.
1995), Mediterranean (Iaccarino 1985)
and Southern Cyprus (Krasheninnikov
& Kaleda 1994) and as the Praeorbu-
lina glomerosa curva Zone in south-
ern
mid-latitudes
(Jenkins
1985).
Zone Praeorbulina glomerosa curva
is attributed to the Langhian Stage
(16.1—15.1 Ma) (Berggren et al. 1995).
In the studied material, this interval is
correlated with nannoplankton Zone
NN5 (Martini 1971; Perch-Nielsen
1985) (Fig. 7) according to the presence
of the species Sphenolithus heteromor-
phus and absence of Helicosphaera am-
pliaperta (see Figs. 2 and 5).
The foraminiferal species Orbulina
suturalis and O. bilobata (Kalaycôlar,
samples 6—14, Fig. 2 and Ku çusofulu,
samples 8—16, Fig. 5) indicate Zone Or-
bulina suturalis (Jenkins 1985; Iaccari-
no 1985) that is correlated with the
upper part of Langhian Stage and with
the Serravalian (15.1—12.7 Ma). The
presence of Sphenolithus heteromor-
phus in the sections of Kalaycôlar (sam-
ples 6, 7, Fig. 2) and Ku çusofulu
(samples 8—10, Fig. 5) gives evidence
for the standard nannoplankton Zone
NN5 and its absence in the overlying
strata may indicate Zone NN6.
Paleoenvironmental
interpretations
The foraminiferal species Globigeri-
na falconensis is a temperature sensi-
tive taxon and its presence reflects cold
to subtropical water conditions (water
temperature 2—20 ºC) (Parker & Berger
1971; Thunell 1977; Cullen & Prell
1984).
Distribution
and
percentage
abundances of G. falconensis in the
western and eastern fans of Cingöz For-
47
BIOSTRATIGRAPHY OF THE MIOCENE SUBMARINE FAN (SOUTHERN TURKEY)
mation varies between 1—6 % (see Figs. 2 and 5), so, pres-
ence of this species indicates temperate to cold sea surface
waters. The locality Kalaycôlar, western fan of the Cingöz
Formation in an exception. The numbers of G. falconensis
fall to about 1—2 % of assemblage during Serravalian (see
Figs. 2 and 5). This phenomenon may indicate input of
warm waters.
Concerning calcareous nannoflora, higher numbers
(22—95 %) of Coccolithus miopelagicus, C. pelagicus,
Reticulofenestra pseudoumbilica and R. haqii support
temperate to cold water conditions (McIntyre et al. 1970;
Bukry 1973; Siesser & Haq 1987; Wei & Wise 1989)
whereas species that are mentioned as tropical to temper-
ate latitude taxa, such as genera Discoaster, Spheno-
lithus
and
Helicosphaera
form
ca.
5—55 %
of
assemblage. The exception is the Serravalian deposits at
the locality of Kalaycôlar, western fan that provided
higher numbers of tropical to temperate latitude nanno-
fossils with increasing percentages from 30 to 50—55 %
and decreasing numbers of temperate to high-latitude
taxa (25—30 %). These observations support the theory
that the sea-surface waters were relatively cold in the
depositional area of the Cingöz Formation in the Lang-
hian but during the Serravalian the sea-surface waters
were getting warm especially in the area of the western
fan. It was caused rather by warm water currents than by
the change of environmental conditions (Figs. 2, 5). Nev-
ertheless, the different character of the nannofossil as-
semblages in the western and eastern fans may also
indicate different ecological conditions. Moreover, dis-
coasters appear during Zone NN6, Serravalian in the
western fan, but in the eastern fan were not recorded. Ac-
cording to Young (1999) discoasters reflect oligotrophic
environments.
According to the distribution of trace fossil content, the
inner part of both fans represent Skolithos-Cruziana ichno-
facies and eutrophic condition. However, the middle part of
both fans have mixed ichnoassemblages (Skolithos-Cruzi-
ana ichnofacies and Nereites ichnofacies) that show
eutrophic-oligotrophic conditions while the outer fans indi-
cate Nereites ichnofacies, and oligotrophic conditions. The
distributions of the trace fossil assemblages show that the
eastern fan has more mixed assemblages than the western (in
the middle of the fan). On the other hand, the fan fringe envi-
ronment has Ophiomorpha isp. It can be explained by the im-
port of its trace marker within stronger turbidity currents from
the inner part of a deep-sea fan, or by normal ‘planned’ colo-
nization (Uchman & Demircan 1999a,b) (Figs. 2, 5).
Fig. 7. Correlation schema of the standard nannoplankton zones
with results of this study.
Fig. 6. Correlation schema of the planktonic foraminiferal zones with results of this study.
48
DEMùRCAN and YILDIZ
Conclusions
The sediments of the western fan (Kalaycôlar section)
and eastern fan (Ku çusofulu section) of the Cingöz For-
mation, southern Turkey contained well preserved plank-
tonic foraminifers and calcareouss nannofossils.
The assemblages of planktonic foraminifers comprise 11
species of 6 genera and are correlated with the Praeorbuli-
na glomerosa curva and Orbulina suturalis Zones. The
calcareous nannofossil associations are composed of 27
species of 10 genera and give evidence for the standard
nannoplankton Zones NN5 Sphenolithus heteromorphus
and NN6 Discoaster exilis. According to the biostrati-
graphic data, sediments of the Cingöz Formation are at-
tributed to the Langhian and Serravalian Stages of the
Middle Miocene.
In the depositional area of the Cingöz Formation, the
distribution and percentage abundances of temperature
sensitive planktonic foraminifers and calcareous nanno-
fossils indicate temperate to cold sea waters in the Lang-
hian—Serravalian interval. A different situation is found
in the Serravalian sediments of the western fan where cal-
careous nannofossils give evidence for the rise in temper-
ature caused probably by warm water currents and the
occurrence of discoasters reflects oligotrophic condi-
tions.
Fig. 8. a – Ophiomorpha isp., endichnial full-relief in coarse—medium-grained sandstone, inner fan; b – Thallassinoides isp., endich-
nial full-relief in medium-grained sandstone, middle fan; c – Halopoa annulata (Uchman), hypichnial full-relief in fine-grained sand-
stone, levee and inter channel; d – Zoophycos isp., and Phycodes isp., endichnial semi-relief in medium—fine-grained sandstone, fan
fringe/middle fan; e – Zoophycos isp., endichnial semi-relief in medium—fine-grained sandstone, slope/middle fan; f – Echinospira
isp., endichnial semi-relief in fine-grained sandstone, middle fan; g – Scolicia vertebralis Ksiazkiewicz, epichnial full-relief in fine-
grained sandstone, middle fan; h – Helminthorhaphe flexuosa Uchman, hypichnial semi-relief in fine-grained sandstone, outer fan
lobes/fan fringe; i – Lophoctenium isp., hypichnial full-relief in fine-grained sandstone, outer fan.
49
BIOSTRATIGRAPHY OF THE MIOCENE SUBMARINE FAN (SOUTHERN TURKEY)
Fig. 9. a – Phymatoderma isp., hypichnial full-relief in fine-grained sandstone, middle fan/outer fan; b – Nereites irregularis (Schaf-
häutl), endichnial/endichnial full-relief in fine-grained sandstone, outer fan lobes/fan fringe; c – Paleodictyon majus Meneghini and Plano-
lites isp., hypichnial semi-relief in fine-grained sandstone, outer fan lobes/fan fringe; d – Paleodictyon delicatum Uchman, hypichnial
semi-relief in fine-grained sandstone, outer fan lobes/fan fringe; e – Scolicia prisca De Quatrafages, endichnial semi-relief in fine-grained
sandstone, middle fan; f – Scolicia strozzii (Savi et Meneghini), hypichnial semi-relief in fine-grained sandstone, middle fan/outer fan;
g – Cosmorhaphe isp., hypichnial semi-relief in fine-grained sandstone, outer fan lobes/fan fringe; h – Cosmorhaphe sinuosa (Azpeita),
hypichnial semi-relief in fine-grained sandstone, outer fan lobes/fan fringe; i – Helminthorhaphe flexuosa Uchman, hypichnial semi-relief
in fine-grained sandstone, outer fan lobes/fan fringe.
The Cingöz Formation consists of 24 ichnotaxa and the
inner part of both fans representing Skolithos-Cruziana ich-
nofacies and eutrophic conditions. The middle part of both
fans have mixed ichnoassemblages (Skolithos-Cruziana
ichnofacies and Nereites ichnofacies) that show eutrophic-
oligotrophic conditions. Nereites ichnofacies and olig-
otrophic conditions are indicated in the outer part of the
eastern fan. According to these data the upper level of the
eastern fan characterized a deeper environment than the
western fan. The fan fringe environment has Ophiomorpha
isp. It can be explained by import of its trace marker within
stronger turbidity currents from the inner part of the deep-
sea fan, or by normal ‘planned’ colonization.
Acknowledgments: This study is a part of Phd. Thesis of
Huriye Demircan. First, we would like to thank Polish
Embassy for Providing scholarship to us for staying in
Poland. Also, authors thank to Prof. Dr. Gilbert Kelling
(Aberdeen University) for selecting this study area and fi-
nancial support, Prof. Dr. Kemal Gürbüz and Prof. Dr. Ve-
dia Töker for advising us.
References
Akça N., Teymur S. & Krebs W.N. 1998: Chronostratigraphy: Foun-
dation to success in the Gulf of Suez, Egypt and Adana Basin,
50
DEMùRCAN and YILDIZ
Turkey. Proceedings of 12
th
International Petroleum Congress
and Exhibition of Turkey October, Ankara 12—15, 216.
Ayhan A. 1978: Geology of the Kozan, Feke, Saimbeyli, Mansurlu
(Adana) area. Miner. Res. Explor. Report, Ankara (Unpub-
lished) 141, 1—45 (in Turkish).
Backman J. 1978: Late Miocene-Early Pliocene nannofossil bio-
chronology and biogeography in the Vera Basin, SE Spain.
Acta Univ. Stockholm Contrib., Geol. 32, 2, 93—114.
Backman J. 1980: Miocene-Pliocene nannofossils and sedimenta-
tion rates in the Hatton-Rockall Basin, NE Atlantic Ocean. Acta
Univ., Stockholm Contrib., Geol. 36, 1, 1—91.
Berggren W.A., Kent D.V., Swisher C.C. & Aubry M.P. 1995: A
revised Cenozoic geochronology and chronostratigraphy. In:
Berggren W.A., Kent D.V., Aubry M.P. & Hardenbol J.
(Eds.): Geochronology, time scale and global correlations: an
unified temporal framework for an historical geology. Soc.
Econ. Geol. Paleont. Miner., Spec. Publ. 54, 121—129.
Black M. 1971: The systematic of coccoliths in relation to the pale-
ontological record. In: Funnell B.M. & Riedel W.R. (Eds.):
The Micropaleontology of Oceans. Cambridge University
Press, 24—611.
Blow W.H. 1956: Origin and evolution on the foraminiferal genus
Orbulina d’Orbigny. Micropaleontology 2, 57—70.
Blow W.H. 1959: Age correlation and biostratigraphy of the Upper
Tacuyo (San Lorenzo) and Pozon Formation, eastern Falcon,
Venezuela. Bull. Amer. Paleont. 39, 1—251.
Blow W.H. & Banner F.T. 1966: The morphology, taxonomy and
biostratigraphy of Globorotalia barisanensis LeRoy, Globoro-
talia fohsi Cushman and Ellisor, and related taxa. Micropale-
ontology 12, 286—303.
Brönniman P. 1951: The genus Orbulina d’Orbigny in the Oligo-
Miocene of Trinidad, B.W.I. contrib. Cushman found.
Foramin., Res. 2, 8—132.
Brönniman P. & Resig J. 1971: A Neogene globigerinacean bio-
chronologic time-scale of the south-western Pacific. Initial Re-
port of Deep Sea Drilling Project 7, 1235—1469.
Bramlette M.N. & Wilcoxon J.A. 1967: Middle Tertiary calcareous
nannoplankton of the Cipero section, Trinidad. W.I. Tulane
Stud. Geol. 5, 93—131.
Bukry D. 1971: Cenozoic calcareous nannofossils from the Pacific
Ocean. Trans., San Diego Soc., Natur. Hist. 16, 27—303.
Bukry D. & Bramlette M.N. 1969: Some new and stratigraphically
useful calcareous nannofossils of the Cenozoic. Tulane Stud.
Geol. Paleont. 7, 42—131.
Bukry D. & Percival S.F. 1971: New Tertiary calcareous nannofos-
sils. Tulane Stud. Geol. Paleont. 8, 46—123.
Chapman F., Parr W.J. & Collins A.C. 1934: Tertiary forminifera of
Victoria, Australia. The Balcombian deposits of Port Phillip.
Part III. J. Linn. Soc. London, Zool. 38, 77—553.
Cullen J.L. & Prell W.L. 1984: Planktonic foraminifera of the
Northern Indian Ocean. Distribution and preservation in sur-
face sediments. Mar. Micropaleont. 9, 1—52.
Deflandre G. 1947: Braarudosphaera nov. gen., typed’une famille
nouvelle de Coccolithophoridés actuels a élélments compos-
ites. C.R. Seances Acad. Sci., Paris 225, 41—439.
Deflandre G. 1953: Hétérogénéité intrinsèque et pluralité des élé-
ments dans les coccolithes actuels et fossiles. C.R. Seances
Acad. Sci., Paris 237, 7—1785.
Deflandre G. & Fert C. 1954: Obervations sur les coccolitho-
phoridès actuels et fossiles en microscopie ordinaire et člectro-
nique. Amer. Paleont. 40, 76—115.
Demircan H. & Toker V. 2003: Trace fossils in the western fan of
the Cingöz Formation in the northern Adana Basin (soutern
Turkey). Bull. Miner. Res., Exploration 127, 15—32 (in Turk-
ish with English abstract).
Demircan H. & Toker V. 2004: Trace fossils in the eastern fan of
the Cingöz Formation in the northern Adana Basin (southern
Turkey). Bull. Miner. Res., Exploration (in press) (in Turkish
with English abstract).
d’ Orbigny A. 1846: Foraminiferes fossiles du bassin Tertiaire de
Vienne (Austriche). Gide et Comp., Paris, 1—312.
Erten T. 1983: Sedimenthologic and petrographic interpretation of
Gilba well in the XIII. Zone. Turkish Assoc. Petrol. Report 540
(in Turkish).
Gartner S. Jr. 1967: Calcareous nannofossil from Neogene of Trin-
idad, Jamaica, and Gulf of Mexico. Univ. Kansas Paleont.,
Contrib. 29, 1—7.
Gartner S. Jr. 1969: Correlation of Neogene planktonic foramin-
ifera and calcareous nannofossil zones. Trans. Gulf Coast As-
soc. Geol. Soc. 19, 99—585.
Gran H.H. & Braarud T. 1935: A quantitative study of the phy-
toplankton in the bay of Fundy and the Gulf of Marine (in-
cluding
observations
on
hydrography,
chemistry
and
turbidity). J. Biology Board of Canada 1, 279—467.
Grimsdale T.F. 1951: Correlation, age determination and the Tertia-
ry pelagic foraminifera. Proc. 3
th
World Petroleum Congress,
The Hague, Sec. 1, 75—463.
Gökçen S.L., Kelling G., Gökçen N. & Floyd P.A. 1987: Stratigraph-
ic and tectonic evolution of the Çukurova Basin Misis Complex.
Geosaund 14, 231—243 (in Turkish with English abstract).
Gökçen S.L., Kelling G., Gökçen N. & Floyd P.A. 1988: Sedimen-
tology of a Late Cenozoic collisional sequence, the Misis Com-
plex, Adana, southern Turkey. Sed. Geol. 59, 205—235.
Görür N. 1980: Diagenetic evolution of Karaisali limestone (Mi-
ocene). Proc. 5
th
International Petroleum Congress and Exhi-
bition of Turkey, Ankara 123—128 (in Turkish).
Gürbüz K. 1993: Identification and evolution of Miocene subma-
rine fans in Adana Basin, Turkey. (Unpublished) Ph.D. Thesis,
Univ. Kele, 1—327.
Gürbüz K. 1998: Middle Miocene submarine fan system in the
Adana Basin (south Turkey). Bull. Turkish Assoc. Petroleum
Geol. 10, 1, 1—14.
Gürbüz K. & Kelling G. 1991: Evolution of Miocene submarine
fans, northern Adana Basins, Turkey. EUG VI. Strasbourg
24—28, March, Terra Nova 1—342.
Haq B.U. & Berggren W.A. 1978: Late Neogene calcareous plank-
ton bio chronology of the Rio Grande Rise (south Atlantic
Ocean). J. Paleontology 52, 6, 94—1167.
Hay W.W., Mohler H.P., Roth P.H., Schmidt R.R & Boudreaux J.E.
1967: Calcareous nannoplankton zonation of the Cenozoic of
the Gulf Coast and Caribbean-Antillean area, and transoceanic
correlation. Trans. Gulf Coast Assoc., Geol. Soc. 17, 80—428.
Iaccarino S. 1985: Mediterranean Miocene and Pliocene planktic for-
aminifera. In: Bolli H.M., Saunders J.B. & Perch-Nielsen K.
(Eds.): Plankton Stratigraphy. Cambridge University Press,
283—314.
Jenkins D.G. 1964: A new planktonic foraminiferal subspecies from
the Australasian Lower Miocene. Micropaleontology 10, 72.
Jenkins D.G. 1985: Southern mid-latitude Paleocene to Holocene
planktic foraminifera. In: Bolli H.M., Saunders J.B & Perch-
Nielsen K. (Eds.): Plankton Stratigraphy. Cambridge Universi-
ty Press, 263—283.
Kamptner E. 1948: Coccolithen aus dem Torton des inneralpineen
Wiener Beclens. Sitz. Ber. Österr., Acad. Wiss. Math-Naturw.
KI. 1, 157, 1—16.
Kamptner E. 1952: Das mickroskopische stadium des skelettes der coc-
colithineen (kalkflagellaten). Mikroskopie 7, 44—232, 86—375.
Kamptner E. 1963: Coccolithinee-skelettreste aus Tiefseeablagerun-
gen des Pazifischen Ozeans. Ann. Naturhist. Mus., Wien 66,
139—204.
Ketin ù. 1966: Tectonic units of the Anatolia. Bull. Miner. Res. Ex-
plor. 66, 20—34 (in Turkish).
51
BIOSTRATIGRAPHY OF THE MIOCENE SUBMARINE FAN (SOUTHERN TURKEY)
Kelling G., Gökçen S.L., Floyd P.A. & Gökçen N. 1987: Neogene
tectonics and plate convergence in the eastern Mediterranean.
New data from southern Turkey. Geology 15, 425—429.
Krasheninnikov V.A. & Kaleda K.G. 1994: Stratigraphy and lithol-
ogy of Upper Cretaceous and Cenozoic deposits of the Key
Peradhi section (Neoautochthon of southern Cyprus). In:
Krasheninnikov V.A. & Hall J.K. (Eds.): Geological structure
of the north-eastern Mediterranean. 195—264 Jerusalem, Israel.
Martini E. 1965: Mid-Tertiary calcareous nannoplankton from Pa-
cific deep-sea cores. In: Whittard W.F. & Bradshaw R.B.
(Eds.): Submarine geology and geophysics. Proc. 17
th
Symp.
Colstom Res. Soc. London, Butterworhs, 393—411.
Martini E. 1971: Standard Tertiary and Quaternary calcareous nan-
noplankton zonation. In: Farinacci A. (Ed.): Proc. II. Plank-
tonic Conference Roma 1970, 2, 85—739.
Martini E. & Bramlette M.N. 1963: Calcareous nannoplankton
from the experimental Mohole drilling. J. Paleontology 37,
56—845.
Mc Intyre A., Bè A.W.H. & Roche M.B. 1970: Modern Pacific coc-
colithoporida: a paleontological thermometer. Trans. N.Y.
Acad. Sci. 32, 720—731.
Mutti E. 1985: Turbidite system and their relations to depositional
sequences. In: G.G. Zuffa (Ed.): Provenance of Arenites.
Riedel, Dordrecht, 65—93.
Mutti E. & Normak W.R. 1987: Comparing examples of modern
and ancient turbidite system; problems and concepts. In: Leg-
gett J.K. & Zuffa G. (Eds.): Marine clastic sedimentology.
Graham and Trotmen, London, 1—38.
Müller C. 1974: Nannoplankton aus dem Mittel-Miozän von Walber-
sdorf (Burgenland). Senckenbergiana. Lethaea 55, 389—405.
Naz H. & Çuhadar Ö. 1988: Facies analyses and relation environ-
ment at the Meydanderesi measured stratigraphic section of
transgressive Lower-Middle Miocene sediments in the XIV
Zone Adana Basin. Turkish Assoc. Petrol. Report 1278, 1—19
(in Turkish).
Nazik A. & Gürbüz K. 1992: Planktonic foraminifera biostratigra-
phy of Lower-Middle Miocene aged submarine fan at the
Karaisali-Çatalan-E ner region (NW Adana). Geol. Bull. Tur-
key 1, 35, 67—81 (in Turkish with English abstract).
Nazik A. & Toker V. 1986: Foraminifer biostratigraphy of Mi-
ocene sequence in the Karaisali area. Bull. Miner. Res. Explor.
103—104 (in Turkish with English abstract).
Nishida S. 1971: Nannofossils from Japan IV. Trans. Proc. Pale-
ont. Soc. Japan New Ser. 83, 143—61.
Özgül N. 1976: Some basinal futures of the Taurus. Bull. Geol.
Soc. Turkey 19, 1, 65—78 (in Turkish with English abstract).
Özgül N., Metin S. & Dean W.T. 1972: Palaeozoic stratigraphy and
fauna of the Tufanbeyli-Adana area (eastern Taurus). Bull. Min-
er. Res. Explor. 79, 9—16 (in Turkish with English abstract).
Özgül N., Metin S., Göger E., Bingöl I., Baydar O. & Erdo an B.
1973: Cambrian-Tertiary rocks in the Tufanbeyli region (east-
ern Taurus, Adana). Bull. Geol. Soc. Turkey 16, 1, 82—100 (in
Turkish with English abstract).
Palmer K.P. 1940—1941: Foraminifera of the Upper Oligocene
Cojimar Formation of Cuba. Mem. Soc., Cubana Hist., Nat.
14, 1, 35—19; 2, 113—132; 4, 277—304; 15, 2, 181—200; 3,
281—306.
Parker F.L. & Berger W.H. 1971: Faunal and solution patterns of
planktonic foraminifera in surface sediments of the South Pa-
cific. Initial Report of Deep Sea Drilling Project 18, 73—107.
Perch-Nielsen K. 1984: Validation of new combinations. INA News-
letter 6, 1, 6—42.
Perch-Nielsen K. 1985: Cenozoic calcareous nannofossils. In: Bolli
H.M., Saunders J.B. & Perch-Nielsen K. (Eds.): Plankton
stratigraphy. Cambridge University Press, 427—554.
Reuss A.E. 1850: Neue foraminiferen aus den Schichten des Öster-
reichischen Tertiärbeckens, Denkschr. Acad. Wiss. Wien.,
Math., Naturwiss., CI. 55, 17—182.
Roth P.H. 1970: Oligocene calcareous nannoplankton biostratigra-
phy. Eclogae Geol. Helv. 63, 799—881.
Schmidt G.C. 1961: Stratigraphic nomenclature for the Adana re-
gion. Petroleum District VII. Petroleum Administration Bull. 6,
47—63.
Schiller J. 1930: Coccolithineae. In: Dr. L. Rabenhorsf’s kryptoga-
men-Flora von Deutschiand. Österreich und der Schweiz.
Acad. Verlagsges, Leipzig, 10, 2, 89—267.
Seilacher A. 1967: Bathymetry of trace fossils. Mar. Geol. 5, 415—428.
Siesser W.G. & Haq B.U. 1987: Calcareous nannoplankton. In:
Broadhead T.W. (Ed.): Fossil prokaryotes and protists: Notes
for a short course. Univ. Tenn. Dep. Geol. Sci. Stud. Geol. 18,
87—127.
Sullivan F.R. 1964: Lower Tertiary nannoplankton from the Cali-
fornia Coast Ranges. 1. Paleocene. Univ. California Publ.
Geol. Sci. 44, 163—227.
engör A.M.C., Yôlmaz Y. & Sungurlu O. 1985: Tectonics of the
Mediterranean Cimmerides: Nature and evolution of the west-
ern termination of Palaeo-Tethys. In: Dixon J.E. & Robertson
A.H.F. (Eds.): Geol. Evolution Eastern Mediterranean Geol.
Soc. Spec. Publ., Oxford 17, 77—112.
Takayama T. 1967: First report on nannoplankton of the Upper
Tertiary and Quaternary of the soutern Kwanto Region. Jpon.
Jhb. Geol. Bundesanst, Wien 110, 98—169.
Uchman A. & Demircan H. 1999a: A Zoophycos group trace fos-
sils from Miocene flysch in southern Turkey: Evidence for a
U-shaped causative burrow. Ichnos 6, 4, 251—259.
Uchman A. & Demircan H. 1999b: Trace fossils of Miocene deep-
sea fan fringe deposits from the Cingöz Formation, southern
Turkey. Ann. Soc. Geol. Pol. 69, 125—135.
Uchman A., Demircan H., Toker V., Derman S., Sevim S. & Szulc
A. 2002: Relative sea-level changes recorded in borings from
a Miocene rocky shore of the Mut Basin, southern Turkey.
Ann. Soc. Geol. Pol. 72, 263—270.
Ünlügenç Ü.C. & afak Ü. 1992: Environmental interpretation of
the Early Miocene deposits (Kaplankaya Formation) in the
Adana Basin. Geosaund, Adana, October 20, 1—363.
Ünlügenç Ü.C. Demirkol C. & afak Ü. 1993: Stratigraphic-sedi-
mentological futures of the Karsanti Basin sediments in N-NE
Adana Basin. Proc. Suat Erk Geol. Symposium, Ankara 215—227
(in Turkish).
Thunell R.C. 1977: Distribution of recent planktonic foraminifera
in surface sediments of the Mediterranean Sea. Mar. Micropal-
eontology 3, 147—173.
Todd R. 1954: Appendix. In: Todd R., Cloud P.E. Jr., Low D. &
Schmidt R.G. (Eds.): Probable occurrence of Oligocene on
Spain. Amer. J. Sci. 252, 82—673.
Toker V. & Yôldôz A. 1991: Nannoplankton biostratigraphy of
Hatay region. Proc. Ahmet Acar Geol. Symposium, Adana
199—211 (in Turkish with English abstract).
Toker V., Özgür S. & Yôldôz A. 1996: Planktic foraminifera and
nannoplankton standard zonation of Miocene sediments in the
Taurus Belt and changing of sea surface water temperature.
Bull. Turkish Assoc. Petrol. Geol. December 8, 1, 35—51 (in
Turkish with English abstract).
Wallich G.C. 1877: Observations on the coccosphere. Ann. Mag.
Natur. Hist., Ser. 4, 16, 39—322.
Wei W. 1988: A new technique for preparing quantitative nanno-
fossil slides. J. Paleontology 62, 472—473.
Wei W. & Wise W.S. Jr. 1989: Paleogene calcareous nannofossil
magnetobiochronology results from Atlantic initial report of
deep sea drilling Project Site 516. Mar. Micropaleontology, 14,
152—199.
Yalçôn N.M. & Görür N. 1984: Sedimentological evolution of the
52
DEMùRCAN and YILDIZ
Globigerina falconensis Blow, 1959
Globigerina woodi connecta Jenkins, 1964
Globigerinoides bisphericus Todd, 1954
Globigerinoides subquadratus Brönnimann, 1951
Globigerinoides trilobus (Reuss, 1850) Grimsdale, 1951
Globoquadrina altispira conica Brönnimann et Resig, 1971
Appendix
List of planktonic foraminiferal species mentioned in this study
Globoquadrina dehiscens (Chapman, Par et Collins, 1934) Blow,
1959
Globorotalia peripheroronda Blow et Banner, 1966
Praeorbulina glomerosa curva Blow, 1956
Orbulina bilobata (d’Orbigny, 1846) Palmer, 1941
Orbulina suturalis Brönnimann, 1951
List of calcareous nannoplankton species mentioned in this study
Braarudosphaera bigelowii (Gran et Braarud, 1935) Deflandre,
1947
Coccolithus miopelagicus Bukry, 1971
Coccolithus pelagicus (Wallich, 1877) Schiller, 1930
Coronocyclus nitescens (Kamptner, 1963) Bramlette et Wilcoxon, 1967
Dictyococcites productus (Kamptner, 1963) Backman, 1980
Discoaster aulakos Gartner, 1967
Discoaster exilis Martini et Bramlette, 1963
Discoaster variabilis Martini et Bramlette, 1963
Helicosphaera burkei Black, 1971
Helicosphaera intermedia Martini, 1965
Helicosphaera kamptneri Hay et Mohler in Hay et al., 1967
Helicosphaera sellii Bukry et Bramlette, 1969
Helicosphaera orientalis Black, 1971
Helicosphaera philippinensis Müller, 1981
Helicosphaera walbersdorfensis Müller, 1974
Pontosphaera inconspicua (Sullivan, 1964) Perch-Nielsen, 1984
Pontosphaera japonica (Takayama, 1967) Nishida, 1971
Pontosphaera multipora Roth (Kamptner, 1948) Roth, 1970
Pontosphaera scutellum Kamptner, 1952
Reticulofenestra haqii Backman, 1978
Reticulofenestra minutula (Gartner, 1967) Haq et Berggren, 1978
Reticulofenestra pseudoumbilica (Gartner, 1967) Gartner, 1969
Sphenolithus abies Deflandre in Deflandre et Fert, 1954
Sphenolithus capricornutus Bukry et Percival, 1971
Sphenolithus conicus Bukry, 1971
Sphenolithus heteromorphus Deflandre, 1953
Triquetrorhabdulus rugosus Bramlette et Wilcoxon, 1967
Adana Basin. International Symposium on the Geology of the
Taurus Belt, Ankara, 165—172.
Yeti C. & Demirkol C. 1984: Some observations of basic stratigra-
phy in north-north western Adana Basin. Proc. Geol. Soc. Tur-
key, 38
th
. Scientific and Technique Congress, Ankara, 59—61 (in
Turkish).
Yeti C. & Demirkol C. 1986: Detail geological etude of northern
Adana Basin. Miner. Res. Explor. Report, (Unpublished) 8037,
1—187 (in Turkish).
Yeti C., Demirkol C. & Kerey E. 1986: Facies and environmental
aspects of the Kuzgun Formation (Upper Miocene) in Adana
Basin. Bull. Geol. Soc. Turkey, February 29, 81—96.
Yôldôz A., Toker V., Demircan H. & Sevim S. 2003: Palaeoenvi-
ronmental interpretation and findings of Pliocene-Pleistocene
nannoplankton, planktic foraminifera, trace fossil in the Mut
Basin. Bull. Earth Sci. Application Res. Centre Hacettepe Uni-
versity 28, 123—144 (in Turkish with English abstract).
Young J.R. 1999: Neogene. In: Bown P.R. (Ed.): Calcareous nan-
nofossil biostratigraphy. British Micropaleont. Soc. Publ. Ser.
225—266.